Home Case Index All Cases Central Excise Central Excise + HC Central Excise - 2014 (10) TMI HC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2014 (10) TMI 760 - HC - Central ExciseReference application - Whether the Tribunal was correct in merely dismissing the appeal without having taken the Boards Review order into consideration - Held that:- The power conferred upon the Board under Section 35H of the Act is somewhat typical. Normally, the taxing statutes do not provide for any appeal by the Department, against the order passed by the original or assessing authority. It is only the prerogative of the assessee to prefer an appeal against the order of assessment. Thereafter, if the Department suffers any order to its detriment in appeal, it can certainly carry the matter in further appeal to the CEGAT, or such authority as may be prescribed. wherever a departmental authority is conferred with the power to reopen, or review the proceedings, under the Act to satisfy itself, it has either to confirm or modify or set aside the orders, under its consideration. Under Section 35E of the Act, the order passed in the first instance has to satisfy itself about the correctness thereof. However, if it finds that the order under its consideration is not correct, the only course left open to it, is to require an authority under the Act to prefer an appeal before the Board against such an order. Beyond that, it cannot express any view on merits. Even on close verification of grounds of Reference, hardly there exists any element of law in them - Decided against Revenue.
|