Home Case Index All Cases Companies Law Companies Law + HC Companies Law - 2018 (3) TMI HC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2018 (3) TMI 201 - HC - Companies LawChanges in scheme sanctioned - Held that:- Once a scheme is sanctioned and made effective, the changes allowed therein should be minor ones and not wholesale changes which would tamper with the essence of the scheme and if a company desires to modify a sanctioned scheme, though not necessary to do so for the proper working thereof, it is required to follow the procedure prescribed under Section 391 of the Act It should be noted that when an order sanctioning a scheme under Section 391 of the Act is passed, it operates in rem. It affects the rights of several persons including creditors, investors, etc. and also creates liabilities in favour of persons like the Income Tax Authorities. These rights and liabilities became vested once the scheme becomes effective. The windmill business was transferred to Transferee and the Scheme was made effective by Transferee by filing Form 21 with the Registrar of Companies, Transferee having started earning revenue and having filed income tax returns, undoubtedly created rights and liabilities in favour of the Income Tax Authorities. It should be noted that Transferee has filed returns for 3 years before this applications were filed. Therefore, these applications are not just for a simple or minor modification of the scheme. If the Court grants the prayers as sought, the net effect would be of recalling the order sanctioning the Scheme to the extent of windmill business. Just because certain tax benefits have been lost does not mean that the Scheme is not workable. Hence no modifications are required. If the reliefs as sought are granted, would effectively amount to tampering with the essence of the scheme which is impermissible. The basic fabric of the Scheme would change and will go beyond the confines of what the Court while sanctioning the Scheme understood in the provisions of the Scheme.
|