Home Case Index All Cases Customs Customs + HC Customs - 2020 (9) TMI HC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2020 (9) TMI 312 - HC - CustomsClassification of imported goods - BIRD SCARE DEVICE - classified under CTH84362900 or under CTH93040000? - restricted goods or not - rejection of self assessment - request for issuance of DDWC - HELD THAT:- The de-novo proceedings itself is a continuation of the original proceedings commencing from the petitioner's self-assessed bill of entry for clearance of goods, the consequential show-cause notice, as well as the reply of the petitioner. Therefore, the proceedings of the second respondent which culminated into the order dated 17.03.2017, cannot be termed as de-novo proceedings at all, but a continuation of the original proceedings. As such, the second respondent ought to have considered the request made by the petitioner for issuance of DDWC. The first respondent herein while passing orders in the appeal, had remarked that there was no mention of the request of DDWC before the lower Authority and that the Appellate Authority cannot entertain a prayer on which no decision or order has been passed by the lower Authority. Such a statement cannot be sustained for two reasons. Firstly, there was a request made by the petitioner before the second respondent in the reply to the show-cause notice. No doubt, such a request could have been given by way of a separate application and not in a reply - Secondly, the first respondent was of the view that the appeal cannot be entertained on a prayer in which no decision or order has been passed by the lower Authority. As a matter of fact, the grievance of the petitioner before the first respondent in the appeal is that though they had made a specific plea for issuance of DDWC, the plea was disregarded and such a disregard was the basis for filing the appeal. There are no justification on the part of the Appellate Authority in deferring to consider the petitioner's request for the certificate, on the ground that there was no such prayer before the lower Authority. The goods are rightly classified under CTH93039000 - Insofar as the issuance of 'Demurrage cum Detention Waiver Certificate' is concerned, the petitioner is granted liberty to make a fresh application to the second respondent herein and on receipt of the same, the second respondent herein shall take into consideration all the observations made in this order and accordingly pass appropriate orders in accordance with law. Petition disposed off.
|