Tax Management India. Com
                        Law and Practice: A Digital eBook ...

Category of Documents

TMI - Tax Management India. Com
Case Laws Acts Notifications Circulars Classification Forms Manuals SMS News Articles
D. Forum
What's New


Discussions Forum
Home Forum Goods and Services Tax - GST This
A Public Forum.
Anyone can participate to share knowledge.
We acknowledge the contributions of Experts/ Authors.

Submit new Issue / Query

← Previous Next →


Issue Id: - 113576
Dated: 4-4-2018

  • Contents

Dear Sir/ Madam

Public Sector Undertaking of Gaziabad ( Under Ministry of Defence) send Radar to other state for trials on returnable gate pass .

This Radar is developed by PSU and will remain property of PSU only .

My query is- under GST Act , how long this property can be with other state and what is the GST implication on it .

Regards & Thanks in Advance

CA Anita Bhadra

Post Reply

Posts / Replies

Showing Replies 1 to 15 of 16 Records

1 Dated: 5-4-2018
By:- Alkesh Jani


In this regards, my point of view is that, firstly, it is to be ascertain that the said PSU has entered any contract with other state for which consideration is required to be made by other state, if so, as there is no transfer of title of goods, it may be covered under the ambit of supply of service under HSN Code 99731. However, the consideration may be as agreed upon. In the above case, the said radar can be with other state till contracts permit.

Further, if there is no consideration, and as the other state is not using the said radar, for any furtherance of business, it may be out of scope of GST. In this case, also the other state can keep the radar, till agreed upon. However, the PSU may be required to show other state as his additional place of business, as trials are taking place at other state.

Moreover, E-way bill is to be issued irrespective of whether the movement of goods is caused by reasons of supply or otherwise. In respect of transportation for reasons other than supply, movement could be in view of export/import, job-work, SKD or CKD, recipient not known, line sales, sales returns, exhibition or fairs, for own use, sale on approval basis etc.

I request our experts to offer their comments and correct me if mistaken.

2 Dated: 5-4-2018

Trial/testing falls under HSN (SAC) 998346. Who would conduct trials ? What is legal status ?

3 Dated: 5-4-2018

The activity of testing/trial of radar cannot fall under HSN 99731 at all. However, remaining points raised by Sh.Alkesh Jani Ji, are worth consideration to arrive at final decision. The remote possibility of RCM in this case cannot be ruled out. Still full facts are known to.

4 Dated: 7-4-2018

Dear CA Anita Bhadra

Such queries must not be raised/replied on an open forums like TMI as these are very sensitive matter related to Nation's Security. We hope you understand it.sad

Requesting TMI to delete this query along with all replies. Requesting all experts to not to revert on such queries.crying



5 Dated: 7-4-2018
By:- Ganeshan Kalyani


6 Dated: 8-4-2018

Madam, Enemies (various types of criminals) of our country have not respect for any law. Such persons do not read taxations site. Only law abiding citizens and professional (who help law abiding citizens to abide by taxation laws) browse TMI and taxation law sites. Criminals have nothing to do with TMI. TMI helps only those who want to comply with taxation laws of our country.

7 Dated: 8-4-2018

Well, we must know about the word "Snooping" which is being conducted by other countries against our Mother Land.

Irony is that even does not know about it and Government Department/Employees including Customs , Income Tax Department, Excise Department using gmail for communication with the assessee/dealer and as per Hon'ble Supreme Court's guidelines Government Employees can't use gmail, yahoo mail etc for official work as USA/CHINA/Pakistan like countries do snooping in such e-mails to dig out the information which do harm to our country.

Even last week I was attending P/H before Asstt. Commissioner and this matter was raised that no information would be shared if your department sends e-mail by using gmail and showed him the Guidelines of Hon'ble Supreme Court. After going through it we got mail from

We should not do anything directly or indirectly knowingly or unknowingly, Consciously or Unconsciously which could do harm to our Mother Land.

Just read about Isreal and Israelis and about their passion, love and sacrifices toward their country. We are 1.35 bn and just says what our country is doing for us.

Think again.

Long Live Bharat.

Jai Hind.

8 Dated: 8-4-2018

Thanks to M/s.YAGAY and SUN for posting such very useful information.

9 Dated: 8-4-2018

Sometimes the addition of a little information can bring a new perspective to a problem or help you to better understand a person or situation.

Your spirit of patriotism is appreciable indeed.

10 Dated: 9-4-2018
By:- Ganeshan Kalyani

Totally agreeing with M/s.Yagay and Sun.

11 Dated: 9-4-2018
By:- Ganeshan Kalyani

How does a people post their product here as an advertisement. We experts tell them not to do such advertisement without the knowledge of TMI. Similarly people may try to extract information from any source.

12 Dated: 9-4-2018

Thank you so much Alkesh ji for constructive reply.


I appreciate your patriotism and concern for country .

Please try to understand ,it’s a simple GST related query posted by one of the professional in close nit group .

Defence PSU developing Radars and sending for trials is not at all secret Act . Its absolute general query of GST implications . No where its mentioned about secret codes etc .

Still if admin & other experts feel is inappropriate , I render my apology . Kindly delete the query .


CA Anita Bhadra

13 Dated: 9-4-2018

Thanks to all for their understanding on this sensitive matter. In our view, whenever we do any task, job or make any decision in our life for our fulfilling of wants (but not needs), then we should see it on the basis of following aspects,

  1. Whether it is environmental friendly?
  2. Whether it is in the interest of my Country & my Earth?

Now coming back to your query, in our view since it is capital goods then limitation period is 3 years i.e. within 3 years it must come back. Further, it must go on delivery challan but not on returnable gate pass as RGP is not a document prescribed under the GST Laws.

14 Dated: 10-4-2018
By:- Alkesh Jani

Dear all,

First of all, I would like to thank all for the views expressed, as well as, their concerns with the security of our mother land. This really touched my heart, the spirit of patriotism is appreciable, but the suggestion that this discussion may be removed or deleted is not acceptable, because, let whole world know that the each participant of this TMI forum, is not only concerns with the tax related matters but believes in COUNTRY FIRST. The TMI, who has provided this platform, where the tax payers or any one raising any query, the experts, naming any will be injustice to others, gives their most valuable advice, and even a bit is left, is filled by others, that too at free of cost, this is also the SERVICE TO THE NATION. In this time when there is lot of ambiguty, few so called experts taking undue advantages of tax payers, the TMI and the experts are extending their services also deserves salute, in my view.

Secondly, with the query raised, I just wish to bring to your notice that, in the query, the name of PSU is not declared and details of radar is also not mentioned, as during the studies of communication radar is one of the topic, however, it is also used in navigation, so I thinks, in no way it may harm our national security, then too, to be aware is the best and in this regards, the CA Anita ji has already extended her apology. However, we all are aware and will be in future also.

Once again I thank all the experts and TMI for providing such a great platform.

My Regards,

15 Dated: 10-4-2018

Sh.Alkesh Jani Ji,. You are 100% right. I agree with you.C.A.Anita Bhadra has not committed any mistake. She took utmost care while drafting query.


Post Reply

← Previous Next →

|| Home || About us || Feedback || Contact us || Disclaimer || Terms of Use || Privacy Policy || Database || Members || Refer Us ||

© [A unit of MS Knowledge Processing Pvt. Ltd.] All rights reserved.
|| Blog || Site Map - Recent || Site Map || ||