Home Case Index All Cases Service Tax Service Tax + AT Service Tax - 2019 (3) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2019 (3) TMI 445 - AT - Service TaxCENVAT Credit - commonly used input services used for providing the output service as well as for undertaking the trading activity - non-maintenance of separate records - Rule 6 of CCR - appellant claimed to have reversed the proportionate credit - Held that - The reversal of Cenvat Credit as claimed by the appellant was not inconformity with Rule 6 of the Rules. Therefore, denial of Cenvat benefit in the adjudication order is proper and justified. Demand of interest - Rule 14 of CCR Held that - The said rule was amended w.e.f. 17.03.2012. The effect of amendment is that the word or was replaced with word and , resulting thereby that Cenvat Credit unless utilized for payment of service tax on the output service, the interest demand cannot be fastened on the Assessee. However, since the reversal particulars and available balance in the Cenvat account during the disputed period was required to be verified, this matter should also go back to the original authority for fact finding with regard to payment of interest by the appellant considering the provisions of both un-amended and amended Rule 14 of the rules. Penalty - Held that - The provisions of Rule 15(3) of the rules read with Section 78 of the Act cannot be invoked inasmuch as there was no element of suppression, misstatement etc., on the part of the appellant in defrauding the Government Revenue - penalty set aside. Appeal allowed in part and part matter on remand.
Issues:
1. Availment of common input services for taxable services and trading activities. 2. Disallowance of Cenvat Credit and imposition of penalties under Cenvat Credit Rules and Finance Act. 3. Reversal of Cenvat Credit and interest demand. 4. Verification of Cenvat account balance and reversal particulars. 5. Imposition of penalty under Rule 15(3) of the Rules. Analysis: 1. The appellant availed common input services for both taxable services and trading activities during the disputed period. The department disputed the availment of such common input services, leading to show cause proceedings and an adjudication order disallowing Cenvat Credit amounting to ?4,72,821. The appellant appealed, and the Commissioner (Appeals) modified the order, reducing the disallowance to ?1,71,491 and the penalty under Rule 15(3) to ?1,47,491. The penalty under Rule 15(1) was set aside. The appellant challenged this order before the Tribunal. 2. The Tribunal considered the appellant's contention that it had reversed proportionate Cenvat Credit for the input services used for both output services and trading activities. However, upon review, it was found that the reversal was not in conformity with Rule 6 of the Rules. Therefore, the denial of Cenvat benefit in the adjudication order was deemed proper. Regarding interest demand, the Tribunal noted the amendment to Rule 14, stipulating that unless Cenvat Credit was utilized for service tax payment on output services, interest demand could not be imposed. The matter was referred back to the original authority for verification of reversal particulars and Cenvat account balance during the disputed period. 3. The Tribunal also addressed the imposition of penalties on the appellant. It was observed that the provisions of Rule 15(3) of the Rules read with Section 78 of the Act could not be invoked without elements of suppression or misstatement by the appellant to defraud government revenue. As no such elements were found, the penalty imposed was set aside, and the appeal was allowed in favor of the appellant. 4. In conclusion, the Tribunal disposed of the appeal by setting aside the penalty imposed under Rule 15(3) of the Rules and allowing the appeal in favor of the appellant. The matter was referred back to the original authority for further fact-finding regarding the payment of interest by the appellant in accordance with the provisions of both unamended and amended Rule 14 of the rules.
|