New User / Register | Bookmarks | Annual Subscription | Feedback |
Login: Stay
| Forget Password |
TMI - Tax Management India. Com  

Recent Discussionss:

Excise duty liabilities on one FG use in other FG within the Factory SERIES OF INVOICES 1% interest penalty when cenvat credit reversed without utilising service tax credit on commission service received Treatment of Share Issue Expenses in realtion to increased Authroised Capital Service Tax & Vat Bot charged on Window 8.1 Professional purchased transportation of goods by railway Excise Duty on Tooling developed by Supplier SERVICE TAX ON SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT AND CONSULTING EXPENSES Refund of ST on Services Given to SEZ
Discussions Forum
Home Forum VAT - CST - GST Month 4 2011 2011 (4) This
← Previous Next →

VAT under composition scheme vis a vis service tax - VAT - CST - GST

Issue Id: - 2979
Dated: -26-04-2011
By:- Rishi Raj
VAT under composition scheme vis a vis service tax


Company has appointed a civil contractor for building and the cost break is given below:

Contract Price                           - Rs. 100 crore inclusive of VAT

Service Tax @ 4.12% on 100  - Rs 4.12

Total                                              Rs. 104.12



·It seems that contractor has gone for composition scheme under VAT  (U.P VAT) because no VAT component is shown separately in the invoices as required under composition scheme.

·Service Tax has been charged @ 4.12 % applicable for work contract service under composition scheme.

I have following queries to address the issue :

1. Is it possible for the civil contractor to calculate the VAT liability basis actual material value or standard deduction for labour / services cost ( say  30% for civil contracts) inspite of paying VAT at fixed % under VAT composition scheme?

2. What is the rate of VAT in uttar pradesh under composition scheme?

3. In the very case, service tax is being charged on Rs 100 cr which is inclusive of VAT . However the same is to be charged on excluding VAT amount.  How to compute the excluding VAT component which is under VAT composition scheme?

Post Reply
Previous Posts

Dated: - 09-08-2011
By: - Shruti Gathani

Hello Mr.Rishi Raj,

Answer to your first querry,

the civil contractor has the following options.:

1. Composition scheme as he has charged.

2. Charge Service tax @ 10.3% on Amount = Gross Amount Charged in invoice for the civil contractor's service excluding VAT amount - Value of goods on which VAT is paid (as accepted under VAT laws).

Dated: - 09-08-2011
By: - Shruti Gathani

Hello Mr.Rishi Raj,

Answer to your third query.:

If VAT has been paid under Composite Scheme, then Service tax also has to be charged at composite rate because the value on which VAT has been paid cannot be worked out.

Previous Next


what is new what is new

UpdatesKnowledge SharingSubscription CommunicationNewslettersMore Options

Go to Mobile Website Go To Top
© [A unit of MS Knowledge Processing Pvt. Ltd.] All rights reserved.