Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the ...

Insolvency and Bankruptcy

June 15, 2022

Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the members of tribunal - matter referred to third member - appellant sight that more points to be included in the reference made to third member - this `Tribunal’ is of the earnest opinion that the said `impugned order’ cannot be termed by no stretch of imagination as `an Order’, in the teeth of culling out of `the point of difference’ (between the `Hon’ble Two Members of the Tribunal’) and formulating the same, is just a `Ministerial Act’ (`on Administrative Side’) of the `Tribunal’, without an entry upon any `Adjudicatory Process’. - No appeal is maintainable against the same - AT

View Source

← Previous Next →

Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the ...

Insolvency and Bankruptcy

June 15, 2022

You may also like:

Reference the matter to the larger bench of 3 members by the Single Member Bench - Even if the learned Member hearing this appeal found it difficult to accept the view...

Maintainability of Reference to Third to member - Difference of opinion - Classification of services - internet telecommunication service or not - The decisions, on...

Extension of tenure of the existing Technical Member of the West Bengal Taxation Tribunal - The Administrative Member of the Tribunal has continued by virtue of interim...

Demand - Revenue neutral exercise - Whether the pre-deposit is to be waived on the basis of revenue neutrality assessed by Member (Judicial) or pre-deposit should be...

Scheme of faceless assessment - the time given to the petitioner to show cause was virtually of three days only - It is deemed appropriate that rather than this Bench,...

Addition of bogus sales - difference in opinion between learned Members constituting the bench - The appellate tribunal (Third Member) addressed the dispute arising from...

Constitution of the GST Appellate Tribunal - Section 110(1)(b)(iii) of the CGST Act which states that a Member of the Indian Legal Services, who has held a post not less...

Manner of disposal of application for advance ruling under Income Tax Act, 1961 - If the Members of a Board for Advance Rulings have differing opinions on any point, it...

Validity of order of the tribunal - The matter was heard by the Member (Judicial) of the Tribunal, however, the decision has been delivered by the Member (Technical) of...

Demand of service tax - Management consultancy service - activity of running, operating and managing the entire hotel business - As both Members have a difference of...

Stay of recovery - recovery of tax from its debtors - Tribunal could not have directed recovery of tax from its debtor, who was not a party to the proceedings before the...

Principle or the doctrine of mutuality - Tribunal for the earlier years, has held that even if there are non-permanent members, non-life members, temporary or honorary...

Maintainability of appeal before tribunal - Seizure of goods - Section 110(A) - Two member bench disagrees with the decision of larger bench - matter referred to the...

Difference of opinion between members of tribunal - difference of opinion on facts - manner in which issues to be addressed - HC

When the Tribunal cannot adjudicate whether an ex-Member of the Tribunal can appear before it as an Authorized Representative or not, the natural consequence of the view...

Quick Updates: