Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2012 (12) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2012 (12) TMI 665 - AT - Income TaxIndo-USA DTAA - payment received from ERAPL(USA) for providing assistance in client coordination titrated as Royalty under Article 12 - Held that:- As seen that the ERAPL serves certain multinational clients in India who have principal offices located outside India and the appellant has agreed to serve EARPL to help to act as coordinating agency as required by such multinational clients. For this purpose, the ERAPL has to pay to the appellant certain amount of annual billings. For the communication channel between ERAPL and its clients the client coordination fees paid to the appellant cannot be termed as Royalty because it is not a consideration for the use of right or to use any of the specified terms mentioned in the definition of Royalty under Article 12 of Indo US DTAA. Since the appellant admittedly does not have a permanent establishment India, the question of taxability of the impugned amount in India would not arise in the absence PE, as provided for in Article 7 of DTAA. In view of these facts, this ground of appeal is decided in favour of the appellant. Lower rate of tax - fees for included services(FIS) - CIT(A)directing to tax @10% instead of @15% - Held that:- As per the Article 12(2)(b) the rate of 10% is applicable in the case of royalty referred to in sub-paragraph of 3(b) and fees for included services as defined under this article that are ancillary and subsidiary to the enjoyment of the property for which payment is received under Para 3(b) of Article. Since the amounts are not royalty being considered either 3(a) or 3(b), the rate of 10% on FIS is not correct. There is nothing on record that indicates that rate specified under Sub-Article (2)(b) is applicable and not (2)(a)(ii). Therefore, upholding the Revenue ground direct the AO to tax the above amounts confirmed by CIT(A) as FIS at 15% of the rate - in favour of revenue.
|