Home Case Index All Cases Central Excise Central Excise + HC Central Excise - 2015 (12) TMI HC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2015 (12) TMI 1211 - HC - Central Excise100% EOU - payment of duty at the time of debonding - Revenue directs Assessee to pay duty in cash whereas assessee wants to pay through CENVAT Credit - Held that:- In case of similarly situated persons, namely, M/s Alps Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. and others, as stated in paragraph-9 of the memorandum of petition, the respondent authorities have permitted them to discharge the excise duty foregone from the Cenvat credit account instead of the cash payment. The petitioners have produced on record a copy of a communication dated 21.11.2014 of the Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise, Division-II, Ahmedabad addressed to the Deputy Development Commissioner in connection with the request for “No Due Certificate” for debonding of Exit out of 100% EOU Scheme by one M/s Alps Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., which clearly shows that the said unit has been permitted to discharge excise duty for indigenously procured duty paid raw materials lying in stock in their factory from the Cenvat credit account. In paragraphs 9 and 14 of the memorandum of petition, the petitioners have clearly stated the names of various parties in whose cases the Ahmedabad Commissionerate has permitted payment of excise duty from the Cenvat credit account. - Besides, the petitioner company is a reputed well established Pharmaceutical Company and hence, the interest of the revenue is in no manner jeopardized if the interim relief, as prayed for, is granted, whereas the petitioner company would have to face a cash crunch if called upon to pay the excise duty foregone in cash, whereas its Cenvat credit account would remain unutilized. Besides, as pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioners, ultimately the excise duty foregone which is to be paid in cash, is going to be added back to the amount of Cenvat credit lying in the account of the petitioners, under the circumstances, the petitioners have clearly made out a prima facie case in their favour. When different companies situated in different regions of the country, are granted a particular benefit, the petitioner therein which was situated in Gujarat, was also entitled to the similar treatment. As noted hereinabove, various assessees, including the assessees situated within the jurisdiction of Ahmedabad Commissionerate have been given benefit of paying the excise duty foregone from the Cenvat credit account. Under the circumstances, prima facie, there appears to be no reason to deny such benefit to the petitioners. - petitioners are permitted to pay the excise duty foregone from the legally availed Cenvat credit account. Upon the excise duty being paid through the Cenvat credit account, the second respondent shall issue “No Due Certificate” to the petitioners for debonding out of 100% EOU Scheme. - Decided in favour of assessee.
|