Home Case Index All Cases Indian Laws Indian Laws + HC Indian Laws - 2021 (7) TMI HC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2021 (7) TMI 394 - HC - Indian LawsEntertainment Tax - Validity of Government Order passed in G.O.Ms.No.89, Commercial Tax - validity of Registration Department dated 21.07.2011 and the consequential guidelines issued by the second respondent in proceedings dated 09.01.2012 - seeking exemption to the Petitioner's Movie under the Tamil Nadu Entertainment Tax Act - validity of Government Order passed in G.O.(D).No.90 dated 26.02.2014 - date of grant of exemption under Tamil Nadu Entertainment Tax Act from 26.02.2014 - validity of Government Order passed in G.O.No.002 dated 03.01.2012 - direction to constitute a new committee to view and recommend films for grant of exemption to entertainment tax - seeking appointment the Committees, grant of exemptions for movies and formulate a policy decision, which can work free from Favouritism, Nepotism and corrupt activities. HELD THAT:- This Court is of the humble opinion that the Governmental institutions have no heart and life of its own. It remains as a building with infrastructures. It is the women and men of integrity, who injects heart and soul to these institutions for the welfare and benefit of the common people - the institutional integrity includes the engagement of authorities possessing the virtue of integrity and honesty. Once the individual's character is lost, the institutional values are lost, the credibility is lost and therefore, the governmental approach in these aspects must be cautious and in consonance with the constitutional perspectives. The mechanism of control must be far more transparent than that of the system prevailing now. Unless effective steps are taken, the constitutional mandate of effective public administration cannot be provided to the citizen of this great Nation. Thus, this Court has no contrary opinion regarding judicial restraint to be exercised in administrative policies. However, the Courts are bound to express its anguish regarding the happenings in the public Administrations. That exactly is the reason why there is a clash between judicial restraint and judicial activism. Undoubtedly, the Court cannot run the Government. However, the High Court has got a constitutional duty to protect the constitutional principles and the values - While exercising the constitutional powers, Courts cannot close its eyes in respect of such happenings in the public administration. The Government of the day irrespective of the political parties, must think about all these aspects. As far as the present writ petitions are concerned, this Court could easily visualize the possibilities of Favouritism and discrimination - However, for want of evidences and in view of the fact that there is no specific malafide allegations against the persons, this Court is unable to consider the relief as such prayed for. However, the Committees overall exercise was improper as the members of the Committee have certain personal affinity with the Government or the Political leaders, who were ruling the State. The Government of the day is expected to consider the following aspects and appoint Committees and authorities in Government organizations and institutions. (1) The women and men of integrity having merit must be selected and appointed in Expert Committees, Governmental organizations and institutions etc., (2) Integrity and honesty must be the criteria, which is to be assessed at the first instance and the merits are to be considered. When the merits are being equal priority, should be given to the integrity and honesty. (3) All such selections and appointments are to be made in a transparent manner and by providing equal opportunity to all the eligible women and men, who all are eligible for such appointments. All such selection and appointments are to be made beyond the Political affinities, aspirations and ideologies, keeping in mind that it is public appointments. (4) If each Political party appointing their own men in such Expert Committees, if allowed to be continued, then there is no scope for revival of social justice, equality in opportunities, merit and integrity. The Government is expected to revisit the entire process and appointment the Committees, grant of exemptions for movies and formulate a policy decision, which can work free from Favouritism, Nepotism and corrupt activities, enabling the people of this great Nation to get social justice from the Government of the day - Petition disposed off.
|