Home Case Index All Cases Customs Customs + AT Customs - 2024 (3) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2024 (3) TMI 934 - AT - CustomsValuation of imported goods - Cement Carrier ship - rejection of transaction value - redetermination of value - inclusion of handling charges, transportation, cost of insurance and landing charges in assessable value - failure to declare the value of Bunkers on board at the time of delivery at Colombo. Mis-declaring the value of ship by not adding value of transportation, cost of insurance and lending charges - failure to declare the value of Bunkers on board at the time of delivery at Colombo - HELD THAT:- In the present case, though the invoice value of Rs. 26,91,00,000/- was declared at the time of import, as per the prevailing practice, at the request of appellant, it was subject to valuation by Chartered Engineer and as per the valuation report, chartered engineer assessed the value of ship as Rs. 27,00,00,000/- and based on the above said value, it was allowed to clear on payment of proper Custom duty. Now in addition to that, adjudicating authority is adding 20% as cost of transportation, handling charges of 1.125% and 1% of assessable value for confirming demand of Rs. 30,31,174/- - The inclusion of ‘freight’ and ‘insurance’ in the assessable value in commercial parlance, is designated as ‘CIF’ in transactions. The vessel, ever coursing the seas and oceans, does not take on additional insurance merely for the purposes of movement to a destination for registration and the cost of self-propulsion does not add to the value of the vessel. Moreover as per the estimated voyage cost produced by the appellant, they have added cost of Rs. 1,70,595/- towards cost of voyage and other expenses for the fuel from Colombo to Mangalore Port and paid customs duty. Consequently, the enhancement of ‘assessable value’ beyond the value assessed by Chartered Engineer fails on every count. Adding the cost of Bunkers, based on the balance quantity of Bunkers at Mangalore port - HELD THAT:- The issue is squarely covered by the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme court in the matter Mangalore Refinery & Petrochemicals Ltd. Vs. CC, Mangalore, [2015 (9) TMI 245 - SUPREME COURT] where it is held that the quantity actually received into the shore tank in port in India should be the basis for payment of Customs duty, being the goods imported into India. Considering the law laid down by the apex court, demand of duty for the balance quantity of Bunkers available in Colombo at the time of delivery of the ship cannot be added towards the cost of Bunkers. Regarding value, as per the request of the appellant, Chartered Engineer carried out survey and as per the report No. AR/016/2011-12 dated 09.05.2011, value assessed the as Rs 27 Crores. Hence this appeal is allowed by accepting the assessable value of the goods as Rs. 27 Crores and additional demand of customs duty against cost of transportation, insurance and handling charges as demanded in the impugned order is set aside - Since there is no suppression of fact, confiscation of the ship and fine and penalty imposed by the adjudicating authority is set aside. The impugned order modified to the extent of confirming assessable value as Rs. 27 Crores. Appeal allowed in part.
|