Home Case Index All Cases GST GST + AAAR GST - 2024 (4) TMI AAAR This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2024 (4) TMI 409 - AAAR - GSTApplicability of GST - Benefit of exemption - Supply of Services by Residents’ Welfare Association (RWA) - contributions towards the corpus fund made by the members of the RWA - whether this money is in the form of a deposit or an advance payment - CGST/ SGST on collection of common area electricity charges from the members - HELD THAT:- As per the ‘ICAI Guidance Note on Terms Used in Financial Statements’, a ‘Sinking Fund’ is a fund created for the repayment of a liability or for the replacement of an asset. In the case of a RWA, such sinking/corpus fund is created in order to meet future contingencies e.g., to meet the expenses for structural repairing, reconstruction work etc. RWA creates a sinking/corpus fund which serves as a backup fund for supply of specific services. A member contributes to such funds with an agreed condition that the RWA will provide some specific services in future, as and when required out of the said funds. So, it is pertinent to refer that the contributions towards the sinking/corpus fund are made by the members of the RWA with a presumption that such funds will be used for bearing the burden of expenses of future supply of services like common area maintenance and other future contingencies as may arise. This contribution is thus an acceptance of the offer of guarding future burden of expenses as made by the RWA, i.e. the appellant in this case to its members. This money is never refunded back to the members but is always in the possession of the RWA for bearing such expenses. Hence, such contribution is not of the nature of a deposit in the truest sense of the term but an advance payment made by the members of the RWA for receiving a supply of common area maintenance services to be provided to them by the RWA in future. As a result, the same would be taxable and the appellant will be liable to pay tax at the time of receipt of such amount in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (2) to section 13 of the GST Act. Tax on electricity charges received by the RWA - It is observed that the appellant has collected the electricity charges consumed for common area from its members on pro-rata basis. Further, the tax invoice issued in this case for “Common Area Maintenance” shows a consolidated amount under SAC 999598 where a fixed rate is levied per square feet of the area of the flat. Tax @ 18% has also been charged on the entire amount. This Common Area Maintenance Charge not only includes common area electricity charges but also charges for other services like security, scavenging, water supply, maintenance of garden etc. Any amount collected on account of consumption of electricity has not been shown separately in the said invoice. Thus, services relating to electricity charges are bundled with supply of goods and services for the common use of its members and hence form a part of composite supply where the principal supply is the supply of common area maintenance services. Therefore, the rate of the principal supply i.e., GST rate on maintenance of the premise would be applicable. The WBAAR Ruling is thus confirmed and the Appeal stands rejected.
|