Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2019 (8) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2019 (8) TMI 613 - ITAT HYDERABADAllowability of difference of conversion of FCNR loan into rupee loan - assessee has to absorb the exchange difference at the time of conversion of FCNR loan into rupee loan - AO stated that restatement of the loan resulted in enhancement of principle amount being related to acquisition of plant and machinery, the conversion loss has direct nexus with the acquisition of capital asset and hence, it is a capital loss - CIT(A) dismissed the appeal holding that the provisions of section 43A is applicable in this case - HELD THAT:- In our view, section 43A has no application considering the fact that the fixed assets were purchased in Indian currency and only the term loan was converted into FCNR and back to rupee loan. The provisions of section 43A are applicable only when the assessee acquires any asset in any previous year from a country outside India and in consequence of a change in the exchange rate, there may be increase or decrease in the liability as expressed in Indian currency as compared to the liability at the time of acquisition of such asset and at the time of settlement. Since, the assets acquired by assessee are not in foreign currency, the provisions of section 43A are not applicable. Let us consider that the assessee has availed rupee loan of ₹ 1 lakh from Syndicate Bank @ interest cost of 10% and later assessee converts the same into FCNR loan with the interest rate of 5%. The assessee services the FCNR loan and at the time of availing the FCNR loan, assessee aware that it is taking interest rate benefit but at the same time, there is exposure of foreign rate fluctuation. Subsequently, assessee converts the FCNR loan into rupee loan during this AY and due to exchange fluctuation, the liability of the assessee towards term loan increases to, let us say, ₹ 1,05,000/-. The original term loan availed by the assessee remains same but due to exchange fluctuation, the assessee takes the additional burden of ₹ 5,000/-. The question before us is, how to treat the above loss of ₹ 5,000/-. The assessee has converted the rupee loan into FCNR in order to take the interest benefit. It is purely a business decision and at the time of conversion, it is aware that there is exposure to the fluctuation of currency rates. Again, assessee converted the FCNR loan into rupee loan, the assessee has absorbed the exchange difference, it definitely falls under business decision and falls within the ambit of section 37. As explained earlier, the original term loan availed by assessee has not changed and remain same and there is no impact on the value of fixed assets since it is acquired in Indian currency. Therefore, it cannot be held that the capital value of the asset or liability has undergone change. Hence, as per the above decision, we allow the grounds raised by the assessee.
|