Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2011 (9) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2011 (9) TMI 204 - AT - Income TaxArm's length price (ALP) - Transactions with Associated Enterprises (AE) TPO held that cost plus compensation @ 5% of cost of the assessee is not at arm’s length and he decided that it is not reflecting the profit attributable to the assessee. -held that:- In assessee’s case, the associated enterprise has been receiving the mark up as 5% of the FOB value of exports effected by assessee by applying its tangible and intangible capacity. The critical and all crucial work is done by assessee. The AE is paying back to the assessee only on the basis of cost plus 5% mark up. Such an arrangement cannot be said at arms length. In our considered view, such method will go against the basic normal business sense, as inefficient and high cost services provided by assessee shall fetch more revenue to the assessee. Such an arrangement on the face of it cannot be said to be at arm’s length. The associate enterprise entered into the agreements for sourcing the goods and the compensation is based on the FOB value of the goods sourced from the India and the assessee performing all crucial and critical function to fulfill the conditions to execute the agreements. Therefore, we find no merits in this plea. The other claim of the assessee that location savings attributable to the end purchaser is also not justified as the assessee has developed many unique intangibles and also human capital intangibles which gives the locational advantage to procure low cost goods which helps the associated enterprise to obtain/retain the business and also benefits the end purchaser. AO as well as the DRP has proceeded on a wrong footing which have given absurd results of adjustments. In view of the fact that majority and crucial services rendered by assessee, the distribution of compensation received by AE @ 5% of the FOB value of the exports between the assessee and the associated enterprise should be in the ratio of 80 : 20. The assessee must get 80% of the total receipt by AE from the ultimate purchasers. AO is directed to compute the arm’s length price in the above manner. - Decided in favor of assessee partly.
|