Home Case Index All Cases Customs Customs + SC Customs - 2012 (9) TMI SC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2012 (9) TMI 57 - SC - CustomsDelay in Order of detention - 14 ½ months in executing the detention order - allegation of fraudulent exports made from Nhava Sheva Port - Held that:- If there is unreasonable delay in execution of the detention order, the same vitiates the order of detention. In the case on hand, though the appellant's brother-the detenu was released on bail on 11.11.2005, the detention order was passed only on 14.11.2006, actually, if the detenu was absconding and was not available for the service of the detention order, the authorities could have taken steps for cancellation of the bail and for forfeiture of the amount deposited. Admittedly, no such recourse has been taken. If the respondents were really sincere and anxious to serve the order of detention without any delay, it was expected of them to approach the court concerned which granted bail for its cancellation, by pointing out that the detenu had violated the conditions imposed and thereby enforce his appearance or production as the case may be. Admittedly, no such steps were taken instead it was explained that several attempts were made to serve copy by visiting his house on many occasions. In the absence of proper explanation for a period of 15 months in issuing the order of detention, the same has to be set aside. Since, we are in agreement with the contentions relating to delay in passing the Detention Order and serving the same on detenu, there is no need to go into the factual details - thus as the detention period has already expired, no further direction is required for his release. The appeal is allowed.
|