Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2019 (8) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2019 (8) TMI 1199 - AT - Income TaxGrant of registration u/s 12AA denied - hostel facility provided to the students by charging fees cannot be regarded as charitable activity in view of proviso to section 2(15) - HELD THAT:- No finding has been recorded by the CIT(E) that the students of Shekhawati Public Senior Secondary School are provided accommodation and stay facility by the assessee society. There is nothing on record which helps determine the reasonability of hostel fees vis-à vis similar facilities provided by any other service provider and in absence thereof, it would be difficult for us to examine the aforesaid contention so raised by the ld AR. During the course of hearing, in order to examine the rent payment made by the assessee society, the Bench has asked the ld AR to submit copies of rent agreement which has been entered into by the assessee society which has subsequently been placed on record and on perusal of the same, it is noted that three of these rent agreements have been entered into with related parties so defined in section 13(3) even as per the audit report for the financial year ended March 31, 2017 relevant to assessment year 2017-18. It needs to be examined whether the rent payment to related parties are commensurate with the area taken on rent and local market/locality conditions where such premises is situated. Such examination will help determine the intent behind setting up of hostel facilities as to whether the hostel facility has been set up as an charitable activity or the rental arrangement has been so structured by way of a cash extraction mechanism where the hostel fees so collected is paid by way of rental payments beyond the acceptable and commensurate amount vis-à-vis area/premises taken on rent so as to benefit the related persons. Merely because there is nominal surplus at the end of the financial year is not determinative of the charitable nature of the activity, however, the whole financial structure which has been designed need to be examined to see the real intent behind such activities. Where the financial structure is so designed to benefit the trustees directly or indirectly through any such rental arrangements which are finally held to be unreasonable or not commensurate with the market conditions, it would be difficult to hold that the hostel facilities are not run with profit motive. However, we are leaving the matter open for the ld CIT(E) to examine taking into consideration the aforesaid discussion. CIT DR also pointed that in the fixed asset schedule of the financial statements for the year ended March 31, 2017, the assessee society has shown asset block of building with written down value of ₹ 43,45,512. It was submitted that on perusal thereof and the fact that there is also rental arrangements, it is not clear in respect of which all properties, the assessee is paying rent and which all properties/building are owned by the assessee society. We find that these are also matters which require to be examined as the same will again have a bearing on the overall financial structure which has been put in place by the assessee society which is an existing running society. Matter is set-aside to the file of the ld CIT(E) to examine the same afresh taking into consideration the aforesaid discussion - Appeal of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.
|