Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2021 (4) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2021 (4) TMI 986 - AT - Income TaxValidity of assessment order us 153A - Approval by the JCIT as required under section 153D - Prior approval necessary for assessment in cases of search or requisition - As per assessee, no assessment order shall be passed unless it is approved by the JCIT - HELD THAT:- From the correspondence between the A.O. on one hand and the JCIT on the other hand and the letter addressed by the JCIT to the Commissioner clearly shows that it was at the stage of discussion and the JCIT could not able to make his mind. Ultimately he simply says that due to shortage of time as he was holding charges for six ranges, it is not possible for him to go into the material deep, therefore, he approved the proposal technically as required u/s 153D of the Act, immediately, after the AO brings to his notice that the assessment is getting time barred. From the above communications, it is obvious that the JCIT has not applied his mind even though there was a discussion between the A.O. and JCIT, the JCIT could not make his mind. Hence, this kind of casual approval/technical approval without going to the matter and without applying his mind to the material available on record is not an approval at all. Therefore, A.O. has no jurisdiction to pass the assessment order. In other words, the assessment order passed by A.O. as confirmed by C.I.T.(A) is void, nullity, non-est, hence, cannot be stand in the eye of law. An irregularity in the assessment order may be rectified by remitting back the matter to the assessment. In the case on hand it is not an irregularity in the assessment order, it is a jurisdictional error. The A.O. has no jurisdiction to pass the assessment order unless the JCIT granted approval. This Tribunal is of the considered opinion that this is not a rectifiable error since it is a jurisdictional error and not an irregularity in the assessment proceeding. Moreover, even if the matter is remitted back, the AO cannot do anything better, since time limit provided under the Act has already expired. Therefore, this Tribunal is unable to uphold the orders of the lower authorities. Accordingly, the orders of both the authorities below were set-aside and the entire assessment order as confirmed by C.I.T.(A) are quashed. Appeals of the assessee stand allowed.
|