1970 (9) TMI 5 - HC - Income Tax

Whether the unutilised portion of the tax exemption computed under section 15C of the Indian Income-tax Act 1922 could be carried forward to be set off against the future profits - Held no

Summary

Issues Involved:
1. Whether the unutilized portion of the tax exemption under section 15C of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, can be carried forward to be set off against future profits for the assessment years 1953-54, 1955-56, and 1956-57.

Detailed Analysis:

Issue 1: Carry Forward of Unutilized Tax Exemption for Assessment Year 1953-54
The primary question was whether the unutilized portion of the tax exemption computed under section 15C could be carried forward to offset future profits. The assessee, a public limited company with a cement factory, claimed that the exemption should be cumulative. The Tribunal, while sympathetic, upheld the plain language of section 15C, which does not provide for carrying forward exemptions. The court agreed, emphasizing that each assessment year is a self-contained unit, and section 15C lacks provisions for carrying forward exemptions. The court concluded that without express words permitting carry-forward, the exemption could not be extended to future years.

Issue 2: Carry Forward of Unutilized Tax Exemption for Assessment Year 1955-56
For the assessment year 1955-56, the question was similar. The assessee argued that the exemption should be cumulative due to losses in previous years. The Tribunal and the court rejected this argument, stating that section 15C provides relief only for the first five years of production and does not allow for cumulative exemptions. The court reiterated that the computation of tax is based on the total assessable income of the previous year, and losses can only be carried forward under section 24, not section 15C. The court held that the plain meaning of section 15C does not support the carry-forward of unabsorbed exemptions.

Issue 3: Set-off of Tax Exemption for Assessment Year 1956-57
The assessee contended that the tax exemption should be set off against future profits due to insufficiency of profits in earlier years. The court rejected this, maintaining that section 15C does not permit carrying forward exemptions. The court noted that the exemption is available only for the first five years of production and is not cumulative. The court also highlighted that section 80J of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which allows for carry-forward and set-off, is not applicable as it is a different provision with a distinct scheme. The court concluded that section 15C does not allow for the carry-forward of exemptions, and the questions were answered in the negative.

Conclusion:
The court held that the unutilized portion of the tax exemption under section 15C of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, cannot be carried forward to be set off against future profits for the assessment years 1953-54, 1955-56, and 1956-57. Each assessment year is a self-contained unit, and section 15C does not provide for cumulative exemptions. The questions were answered in the negative, and the Commissioner was awarded costs.