Tax Management India. Com
Law and Practice  :  Digital eBook
Research is most exciting & rewarding


  TMI - Tax Management India. Com
Follow us:
  Facebook   Twitter   Linkedin   Telegram
Article Section

Home Articles Budget CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI Experts This

Budget 2020 suggestions for salaried persons.

Submit New Article
Budget 2020 suggestions for salaried persons.
CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI By: CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI
January 7, 2020
All Articles by: CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI       View Profile
  • Contents

Here are some suggestions for consideration by honorable Finance Minister in next budget  for salaried  people. 

Standard Deduction:

Standard deduction should be rationalized and certain percentage of salary may be allowed in different slabs instead of ₹ 40K / 50K and salary whichever is low  for aY 2019-20 and 2020-21 respectively. For example, slabs can be:

                           10 % of salary up to Rs. Five lakh

                           7% of salary for amount above five lakh and up to ten lakh.

                          5% of salary above Rs.ten lakh and up to twenty lakh.

                          3% of salary above Rs. Tweny lakh

Therefore deduction shall be as follows for a person having salary income:

Rs. Three lakh ₹ 30K

Rs. Five lakh ₹ 50K

Rs. Ten lakh ₹ 85 K (50 +35)

Rs, twenty lakh   ₹ 135 K  (50+35+50)

In excess of Rs. Twenty lakh ₹ 135K + 3% of salary  which is above Rs. twenty lakh. Therefore

Salary Rs. Thirty lakh   135K + 30K = 165 K

Salary Rs. One crore    135K + 240 K = 375  K

Depreciation:

Depreciation on building, furniture plant and equipment, vehicles , apparatus etc. which are required to maintain suitable standard  of living, physical fitness and in performance of duties should be allowed. Good standard of living and good health will improve productivity.  As personal use will also be there therefore, deduction equal to 50% of normal rate of depreciation can be allowed to salaried people.

Salary earners use some assets like houses, furniture and fixtures, vehicles, computers, mobile phones, equipment’s etc. owned by them. The use is to some extent in connection with employment but depreciation is not allowed to them though such assets also suffer wear and tear. If such assets are used by self-employed persons or business person, including by providing such assets to employees, they become entitled to depreciation allowance. As these assets suffer wear and tear and obsolescence it is desirable that depreciation should be allowed on such assets to salary earner also as a deduction from salary income.

Long-term savings and investments:

Amount of deductions and exemptions  for long-term savings and   investments should be increased.

Business loss should be allowed:

Salaried persons who have saved capital, have experience and knowledge and have contacts also , can enter into business. There is risk in business, therefore, in case in business loss is suffered the same should be allowed to be set off against salary income. In this regard businesses should generate employment and investment of capital in infrastructure ( fixed assets) should take place. And some business  can be put into negative list for example speculation loss, gambling loss, etc.  should not be allowed to be set off.

Depreciation on house properties can be allowed:

Depreciation on house properties acquired and used to let out should be allowed to all including salaried people. This will boost investment in infrastructure.

Clean all sins schemes should be introduced:

Greed is god made, power makes people greedier. Both result into corruption. This is reason that people in power by exercisable authority or denial of exercise of authority have scope to make extra money by obliging others. 

It is well known that people in service of government and private sectors both who enjoy powers are more likely to be corrupt then others  because power and greed and scope of exercising power can  lead to extra income (upri kamai). Ground reality is that such extra income is well known in social circles.

Unaccounted income and wealth can be found with such persons. Some examples of people having income/ wealth more than known means are just tip of iceberg.

A clean all sins scheme can be introduced for salaried persons (including government servants and politicians)  to disclose their undisclosed income and wealth either in own name or in name of any family member (parents , wife, and children) on payment of tax of 40% assuring that no further question will be asked and there will be no repercussion on their future service or political period as the case may be.

 

By: CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI - January 7, 2020

 

Discussions to this article

 

The suggestions thought by you which is brought down in this article is worth appreciating. I agree with the point that an employee uses his /her own laptop , books etc. Which is brought by him/her own cost. Training are also attended by the key employees whose decision makes impact in the company where they work. Hence, depreciation is a right claim which salaried persons must be entitled to.

CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI By: Ganeshan Kalyani
Dated: January 7, 2020

Certain expenses like marriage of the children etc., may be allowed as deduction. A threshold limit may be fixed for uniformity.

CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI By: DR.MARIAPPAN GOVINDARAJAN
Dated: January 7, 2020

Few suggestions for Senior Citizens:

1) The threshold limit of taxable income of a senior Citizen should be increased from ₹ 3 L to 5 L.

2) As many of the retired employees are either from PSUs or other companies whose main source of income is Interest on FDs, the Interest exemption U/s 80TTB should be increased from ₹ 50K to 100K.

3) To avail the experience gathered by retired senior employees through imparting training to youngsters, a new provision for exemption of Income earned by a senior citizen through training fee with a limit say., ₹ 50K should be inserted. This will give a boost to Senior knowledgeable persons to share their enriched knowledge to new generations.

CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI By: KG WARRIER
Dated: January 8, 2020

Valid suggestion given by Sri Mariappan Sir. And third suggestion given by Sri KG Sir is really noteworthy. Rich experience is not being made use of. New generation is energetic but senior citizen's experience can prove to be torch for young.

CA DEV KUMAR KOTHARI By: Ganeshan Kalyani
Dated: January 8, 2020

 

 

Quick Updates:Latest Updates