Home Case Index All Cases Customs Customs + AT Customs - 2022 (3) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2022 (3) TMI 286 - AT - CustomsMis-declaration and under valuation of imported goods - printed book catalogue - opportunity of personal hearing by the Original Adjudicating Authority not provided - violation of principles of natural justice - HELD THAT:- None of the four noticees of the impugned show cause notice had marked their presence before the original adjudicating authority. Though three dates have been mentioned in the order as the date of personal hearing for all four of them, but it is specifically been recorded in para 39.2 of Order-in Original that the notice for three of these dates were received back undelivered from the postal authorities with respect to the Noticee No. 2, 3 and 4. It is also observed that no reasonable time was granted for these three dates as there has been two days gap in each of the dates (4.8.2017, 7.8.2017 and 9.8.2017). As far as the main noticee/importer is concerned, there is no such mention that notice served to him was received back undelivered . Still Noticee No. 1 has been granted opportunity of being heard by the Original Adjudicating Authority as his matter has been remanded for denovo adjudication. There is no reason in the Order-in-Appeal for distinct decision given for Noticee No.1 while denying the same opportunity of personal hearing to the remaining noticees including the present appellant. In the given circumstances and in the interest of justice, appellant’s case along with that of Noticee No. 3 & 4 is on much better footings as there is apparent admission that notice could not be delivered upon him and the same was received back undelivered. As per principles of Audi Alteram Partam, the first principles of natural justice which requires that none should be condoned unheard, the findings of the Commissioner (Appeals) are held to be highly unreasonable and illegal. The same are accordingly hereby set aside. Matter of present appellant also is directed to be readjudicated denovo - appeal allowed by way of remand.
|