The High Court considered the scope of review jurisdiction ...

Scope of review jurisdiction. Review power distinct from appellate power. It corrects errors, not grievances.

May 30, 2024

Case Laws VAT and Sales Tax HC

The High Court considered the scope of review jurisdiction regarding the inclusion of purchase price of plant and machinery in 'Fixed Capital Investment'. Review power is distinct from appellate power. Recent Supreme Court rulings emphasize strict adherence to Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC. Review jurisdiction safeguards judicial integrity, not for re-argument. It corrects errors, not grievances. Failure to submit judgments does not constitute an error apparent on the face of the record. Mere failure to cite a judgment does not invalidate the original decision. The review application was dismissed for lack of merit.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The High Court considered the scope of review jurisdiction ...

Scope of review jurisdiction. Review power distinct from appellate power. It corrects errors, not grievances.

May 30, 2024

Case Laws VAT and Sales Tax HC

You may also like:

Jurisdiction - power of Tribunal to review its own order - Power of Review has to be granted by statute and the ‘power of Review’ is not an inherent power and therefore...

A review application is maintainable on (i) discovery of new and important evidence which could not be produced earlier despite due diligence, (ii) mistake or error...

The case involves a review petition filed in the Madhya Pradesh High Court seeking to recall an order that dismissed an appeal due to the absence of substantial...

Power to review versus Power to rectify - cancellation of GST registration - the appellate authority erroneously exercised its power under Section 161 of the Act. The...

Scope of Section 29 of the U.P. VAT - The power of re-assessment is quite different and distinct from that of review or of the appellate power. Therefore, the assessing...

Review petition - error on record - power to correct - earlier judgment suffers from error apparent on the face of record and is liable to be recalled/reviewed. The...

Power of tribunal to review application - It is the well laid down proposition of law that ‘in the absence of any power of ‘Review’ or ‘Recall’ vested with the...

Power of Tribunal to recall its earlier order and hear the appeal afresh - power to review or power of rectification – Tribunal committed no error in exercising power...

The HC held that the review application was partly allowed. There was no mistake apparent on record regarding the application of the Supreme Court decision and the...

Power of Tribunal to review the judgment versus Power to re-call - Larger Bench (5 Members) decision - The judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court clearly lays down that...

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - power to review v/s power to reassess - Only material relied upon by the assessing officer, in this case, is the material supplied by...

Power of ITAT to review the order - a statutory authority cannot exercise power of review unless such power is expressly conferred on it. - HC

Petition challenging validity of reopening assessment u/s 148 dismissed. No final order passed, jurisdictional issue raised for first time in review petition. Statutory...

ITAT recalled its earlier order due to discovery of inadvertent errors, specifically the reliance on non-existing case laws identified during suo-moto review. Exercising...

Scope of Judicial Review – Review of the decision of the Settlement Commission - There is limited scope of judicial review - Despite such narrow confines of judicial...

Quick Updates: