The court examined whether the impugned order violated ...

Order Overturned for Ignoring Key Arguments; New Hearing Set to Ensure Fairness and Detailed Justification.

July 23, 2024

Case Laws Customs HC

The court examined whether the impugned order violated principles of natural justice by not considering contentions raised by the petitioner and being non-speaking regarding certain claim heads. The court held that quasi-judicial authorities must record reasons, though not as elaborate as court judgments. Upon examination, the court found that while reasons were specified for classification under CTH 8301, vital contentions regarding GRI and Explanatory Notes were not considered. To balance revenue interests, the court set aside the order on condition that the petitioner remits Rs. 1.75 crore, exceeding 5% of the disputed tax demand under this head, within four weeks. The assessing officer was directed to provide a reasonable opportunity, including a personal hearing, and issue a fresh order within three months after receiving the petitioner's reply.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The court examined whether the impugned order violated ...

Order Overturned for Ignoring Key Arguments; New Hearing Set to Ensure Fairness and Detailed Justification.

July 23, 2024

Case Laws Customs HC

You may also like:

HC found a violation of natural justice where respondent issued a personal hearing notice before reply deadline and subsequently passed an order without considering...

Principles of natural justice violated as petitioner denied opportunity of hearing before passing adverse order. Coordinate bench ruling in BHARAT MINT case affirmed -...

The HC set aside the impugned order dated 9 March 2009 passed by the Special Director (Enforcement) due to inordinate and unexplained delay between the conclusion of...

HC ruled on input tax credit rectification under Section 161 of Delhi GST Act, finding procedural irregularities in the administrative order. The court held that when...

HC found a violation of Section 75(7) where the demand amount (Rs. 59,27,500/-) exceeded the show-cause notice amount (Rs. 28,15,200/-). Despite procedural...

HC invalidated ex parte orders issued by tax authorities due to violation of natural justice principles. The respondent-Department failed to properly serve notices...

The High Court quashed the summary order issued under the GST Act without a detailed order, finding it a violation of principles of natural justice. The court observed...

The Allahabad High Court addressed the denial of a personal hearing in a tax assessment case, emphasizing the mandatory nature of such hearings u/s 75(4) of the U.P. GST...

HC allows writ petition challenging GST recovery order due to violation of natural justice principles. The court found that mandatory personal hearing under Section...

Bench Reconstitution and Order Pronouncement - Whether an order reserved by a bench could be pronounced by a reconstituted bench without considering a subsequent...

HC set aside assessment orders due to procedural deficiencies in tax evaluation. Authority failed to consider complete financial details, particularly regarding tax...

Principles of natural justice - The High Court found merit in the petitioner's argument regarding the violation of procedural fairness, as the impugned order failed to...

HC overturned denial of input tax credit (ITC) u/s 16(4) of CGST/SGST Acts. Court acknowledged petitioner's claim regarding eligibility under newly notified Section...

Violation of principles of natural justice due to absence of appellant's counsel during proceedings. High Court noted counsel's absence on certain dates, but matter...

Procedure relating to sanction, post-audit and review of refund claims - Guidelines issued to ensure uniformity in issuance of speaking order for refund - Details...

Quick Updates: