Interpretation of the phrase "reason to believe" u/s 110 of the ...

Court Rules "Reason to Believe" Must Be Evidence-Based for Customs Searches; Orders Release of Seized Goods.

September 30, 2024

Case Laws Customs HC

Interpretation of the phrase "reason to believe" u/s 110 of the Customs Act, which is a crucial safeguard for authorizing officers to conduct searches. The court examined the legal principles governing "reason to believe," emphasizing that it cannot be arbitrary, capricious, or whimsical, and must be based on material evidence. The officer must independently apply their mind and not merely reproduce statutory words mechanically. The reasons must be self-explanatory and cannot be supported by extraneous material. In the present case, the suspected opinion of local traders that the seized dried areca nuts were of foreign origin was deemed unreliable and unacceptable, as their origin could not be conclusively determined by mere visual inspection. The court held that the seizure memo lacked valid reasons and set it aside, discharging the bank guarantee and ordering the release of the seized goods within three months.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Interpretation of the phrase "reason to believe" u/s 110 of the ...

Court Rules "Reason to Believe" Must Be Evidence-Based for Customs Searches; Orders Release of Seized Goods.

September 30, 2024

Case Laws Customs HC

You may also like:

Release of seized goods - Arecanuts - prohibited goods - reason to believe - The High court finds that the Revenue Authorities failed to present credible and objective...

The High Court considered a challenge to a search and seizure order under the UPGST Act. The court found non-compliance with the mandatory provision of Section 67 as the...

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - Reasons to believe or suspect - huge share transaction - The court held that the reasons provided by the Assessing Officer for...

Validity of provisional attachment order - benefit of Input Tax Credit availed from invoices issued from non-existing firms - It observes that the impugned order lacks...

Validity of order of lower court for release of goods / return of goods to the accused - Smuggling - yellow coloured metallic bars believed to be gold of Foreign origin...

Validity of Search and seizure - In the instant case the record reveals that the Additional Director of Enforcement Directorate without recording the ‘reasons to...

Denial of adjournment request - Release of goods based on forged documents leading to fraud - Customs clearance of imported mobile phones with duplicate IMEI numbers -...

The court examined the validity of search and seizure u/s 132, focusing on the scope of Revenue's power and the "reasons to believe" requirement. It held that the...

This public notice from the Indian Customs Department aims to conduct a sector-specific analysis of the release time for import and export cargo at the Chennai Air Cargo...

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - Reopening based on audit objections - reasons to believe - High Court observed that, reopening an assessment beyond four years requires...

HC ruled in favor of petitioner, ordering release of seized gold jewelry within 7 days. The court determined that Baggage Rules 2016 provision regarding items "carried...

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - reasons to believe - The High court observes that all the issues raised in the notice for reopening were indeed subject to discussion...

The main order rejecting condonation of delay lacks reasons, violating principles of natural justice. It is a well-settled legal position that an affidavit-in-reply...

Reassessment - Validity of notice u/s 148 of the Act – Reason to believe – The material found in post search enquiries could form a “reason to believe“ that income had...

Rule 86A of the Central/State Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017, which allows blocking of the Electronic Credit Ledger, has been held unconstitutional by the High Court...

Quick Updates: