Disallowance of sales commission paid to two Associated ...

Taxpayer's Foreign Commission Payments Upheld; Stock Valuation Method Sent for Review.

October 11, 2024

Case Laws Income Tax AT

Disallowance of sales commission paid to two Associated Enterprises (AEs) being foreign entities - assessee failed to discharge the onus of proving legitimate business requirement and genuineness of payment by submitting relevant documentary proof. CIT(A) deleted the addition without calling for a remand report from the AO, violating Rule 46A. Matter needs to be restored to CIT(A) for adjudicating sales commission again. Sales commission paid to Heubach GMBH - assessee discharged onus, Revenue failed to provide cogent material to disallow, CIT(A)'s order upheld. Sales commission paid to Darlington Enterprises - assessee discharged onus, Revenue failed to provide cogent material to disallow, CIT(A)'s order upheld. Undervaluation of finished/closing stock of Beta Blue - assessee applied weighted average cost method of yearly costs for finished stock and monthly costs for WIP. AS-2 requires fairest approximation of cost incurred. Matter set aside to AO to determine reasons for adopting different methods and allow assessee to justify, after verifying consistent practice and Revenue's acceptance.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Disallowance of sales commission paid to two Associated ...

Taxpayer's Foreign Commission Payments Upheld; Stock Valuation Method Sent for Review.

October 11, 2024

Case Laws Income Tax AT

You may also like:

Under valuation of closing stock of rice - improper maintenance of stock register by the assessee-firm - the method of valuation was adopted by the Ld. AO in closing...

Addition on valuation of closing stock - excise duty on closing stock of its finished goods - exclusive VS inclusive method - although the method of valuation of stock...

Valuation of closing stock - gold and jewellery - AO cannot change the method which was not recognized method as per the prescribed standards for valuation of closing...

Difference in stock valuation - valuation of the closing stock - LIFO or FIFO method - It is an admitted case that the assessee has been continuously adopting the LIFO...

Disallowance on account of valuation of stock u/s 145A - assessee is following exclusive method of accounting for valuing closing stock wherein unutilised MODVAT/Cenvat...

Constitutionality and legality of Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS) II and Notification 87/2016, which mandate the use of the First In First Out (FIFO)...

Addition u/s 56(2)(viib) - Method of valuation of shares - closely held company issues its shares at a premium - The tribunal sided with the assessee, affirming the FMV...

Method of valuation - Rule 11 is adopted when the situation is not covered by any of the other methods of valuation prescribed from Rule 4 to 10A. The method of...

AO rejected DCF method for valuation of shares issued as rights issue to existing shareholders. Instead, AO applied NAV method u/r 11UA determining FMV at Rs.3.07 per...

Reverse charge mechanism on commission paid to foreign commission agents does not attract service tax liability. Documentary evidence shows no direct payment made to...

Valuation of the closing stock - valuation method of "At cost" which is changed to "At cost or market value whichever is less‟ is more prudent - Change in the...

Valuation of closing stock - inclusion of excise duty element - AO adopted the gross method at the time of purchase, and the net method of valuation at the time of...

Additions u/s 56(2)(viib) - it is not denied that the assessee adopted clause (b) of Rule 11UA(2) of the Rules and accordingly obtained a Valuation Report from a...

Valuation of closing stock - the action of the AO of changing the method of valuation of closing stock without pointing out any reason for the rejection of valuation of...

Provision for impairment of stocks - method of valuation of stock - inventory consisted of old/used stock which was categorized as defective, but, repairable stock and...

Quick Updates: