TMI Blog1967 (11) TMI 109X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... nspector Krishnaswami raided the premises of the club. They found respondents 1-5 playing a card game known as Rummy for stakes. At the time of the raid, there were some counters on the table as also money and of course the playing-cards with the players. Respondent No. 6, the Treasurer of the Club, was also present and was holding the stake money which is popularly known as kitty . The 7th respondent is the Secretary of the Club and he has been joined as an accused, because he was in charge of the management of the club. The kitty which the sixth respondent held was ₹ 74.62nP and a further sum of ₹ 218/- was recovered from the table of the 6th respondent. 66 counters were on the table and some more money was found with the persons who were indulging in the game. The evidence of the Circle Inspector is that he had received credible information that the premises of the club were being used as a common gambling house and he raided it and found evidence, because instruments of gambling were found and the persons present were actually gambling. The Magistrate convicted all the seven respondents and sentenced them to various fines, with imprisonment in default. The respon ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... se or not. The Secretary and the Treasurer, who were respectively accused Nos. 7 and 6 were so arraigned as it was thought they came within the reach of s. 4 because they were in the care and management of the club itself. Then there is s. 6 which again is similar but not entirely similar to s. 5 of the Public Gambling Act. This provides for entry for search and entry by police. It lays down as follows :-- If the District Magistrate or the Magistrate of the First Class or the District Superintendent of Police or the Inspector of Police in the city and the suburbs of Hyderabad, on credible information and after such enquiries as he may deem necessary, has reason to believe that any house or premises or enclosure or an open space is used as a common gambling house he shall be empowered to enter or authorise any police officer, not below the rank of a Sub-Inspector to enter with such assistance as may be found necessary, by night or by day, and by force, if necessary, any such house or premises or enclosure or open space, and it shall be proper to arrest all persons whom the said Magistrate or the Superintendent or Inspector of Police finds therein or to allow the Police Officer s ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... he persons present round the table who had cards, counters and the money with them. The learned Magistrate who tried the case was of the opinion that the offence was proved, because of the presumption since it was not successfully repelled on behalf of the present respondents. In the order making the reference the learned Sessions Judge made two points: He first referred to s. 14 of the Act which provides that nothing done under the Act shall apply to any game of mere skill wherever played and he was of opinion on the authority of two cases decided by the Madras High Court and one of the Andhra High Court that the, game of Rummy was a name of skill and therefore the Act did not apply to the case. He also held that there was no profit made by the members of the club from the charge for the use of cards and the, furniture and the room in the club by the players and therefore the definition of common gambling house did not apply to the case. In accepting the reference, the learned single Judge in the High Court did not express any opinion upon the question whether the game of Rummy can be described as a game of skill. _ He relied upon the second part of the proposition which the ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... playing cards we may say that clubs usually make an extra charge for anything they Supply to their members because it is with the extra payments that the management of the club is carried on and other amenities are provided. It is commonly known that accounts have to be kept, stocks have to be purchased and maintained for the use of the members and service is given. Money is thus collected and there is expenditure for running of each section of the establishment. Just as some fee is charged for the games of billiards, ping-pong, tennis, etc, an extra charge for playing cards (unless it is extravagant) would not show that the club was making a profit or gain so as to render the club into a common gambling house. Similarly, a late fee is generally charged from members who use the club premises beyond the scheduled time. This is necessary, because the servants of the club who attend on the members have to be paid extra remuneration by way of overtime and expenditure on light and other amenities has to be incurred beyond the club hours. Such a charge is usual in most of the clubs and we can take judicial notice of the fact. This leaves over for consideration only the sitting fee as ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X
|
