TMI Blog1996 (2) TMI 584X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... trong words indeed - but nothing less would reflect the deep sense of hurt, the hearing of this case has instilled in us. The facts of the case will bear out these opening remarks. Bichhri is a small village in Udaipur district of Rajasthan. To its north is a major industrial establishment, Hindustan Zinc Limited, a public sector concern. That did not affect Bichri. Its woes began somewhere in 1987 when the fourth respondent herein, Hindustan Agro Chemicals Limited started producing certain chemicals like Oleum [said to be the concentrated form of Sulphuric acid] and Single Super Phosphate. The real calamity occurred when a sister concern, Silver Chemicals [Respondent No.5], commenced production of `H' acid in a plant located within the same complex. `H' acid was meant for export exclusively. Its manufacture gives rise to enormous quantities of highly toxic effluents - in particular, iron-based and gypsum-based sludge - which if not properly treated, pose grave threat to mother Earth. It poisons the earth, the water and everything that comes in contact with it. Jyoti Chemicals [Respondent No.8] is another unit established to produce `H' acid, besides some other chemi ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... of Silver Chemicals in January, 1989. It is averred by the respondents that both the units, Silver Chemicals and Jyoti Chemicals have stopped manufacturing `H' acid since January, 1989 and are closed. We may assume it to be so. Yet the consequences of their action remain - the sludge, the long-lasting damage to earth, to underground water, to human beings, to cattle and the village economy. It is with these consequences that we are to contend with in this writ petition. The present social action litigation was initiated in August, 1989 complaining precisely of the above situation and requesting for appropriate remedial action. To the writ petition, the petitioner enclosed a number of photographs illustrating the enormous damage done to water, cattle, plants and to the area in general. A good amount of technical data and other material was also produced supporting the averments in the writ petition. COUNTER-AFFIDAVITS OF THE RESPONDENTS On notice being given, counter-affidavits have been filed by the Government of India, Government of Rajasthan, Rajasthan Pollution Control Board [R.P.C.B.] and Respondents Nos.4 to 8. Since the earliest counter-affidavit in point of time is t ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... e Management replied that this unit was closed for a long time. (e) Re.:Jyoti Chemicals [R-8]: This unit applied for 'No- Objection Certificate' for producing ferric alum. 'No- Objection Certificate' was issued imposing various conditions on April 8, 1988. The 'No-Objection Certificate' was withdrawn on May 30, 1988 on account of non-compliance with its conditions. The consent applied for under Water and Air Acts by this unit was also refused. Subsequently, on February 9, 1989, the unit applied for fresh consent for manufacturing `H' acid. The consent was refused on May 30, 1989. The Board has been keeping an eye upon this unit to ensure that it does not start the manufacture of `H' acid. On October 2, 1989, when the unit was inspected, it was found closed. The Board submitted further [in its counter-affidavit] that the sludge lying in the open in the premises of Respondents Nos.4 to 8 ought to be disposed of in accordance with the provisions contained in the Hazardous Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 framed under Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. According to the Board, the responsibility for creating the said hazardous situation ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... ts into ground water and their spread down the aquifer. Currently about 60 wells appear to have been significantly polluted but every week a few new wells, down the aquifer start showing signs of pollution. This has created serious problems for water supply for domestic purposes, cattle-watering crop irrigation and other beneficial uses, and it has also caused human illness and even death, degradation of land and damage to fruit, trees and other vegetation. There are serious apprehensions that the pollution and its harmful effects will spread further after the onset of the monsoon as the water percolating from the higher parts of the basin moves down carrying the pollutants lying on the slopes - in the holding pond and those already underground. Each of the Respondent Nos.4 to 8 filed separate counter-affidavits. All the affidavits filed on behalf of these respondents are sworn-to by Lt.Gen. M.L.Yadava, who described himself as the President of each of these units. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the fourth respondent, it is stated that it is in no way responsible for the situation complained of. It is engaged in the manufacture of sulphuric acid and had commenced i ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... d closed down completely in January, 1989. It is stated that the unit produced `H' acid to an extent of 20 MT as a trial measure for one month with the permission of the Industries Department. It is no longer manufacturing `H' acid and, therefore, is not responsible for causing any pollution. It is further submitted that it is a small-scale industry and was registered with the District Industry Centre, Udaipur for the manufacture of ferric alum and `H' acid. It began its operation simultaneously with the fifth respondent, Silver Chemicals, and several of the clearances are common to both, as both of them are located together. The trial production of `H' acid, it is stated, took place in January, 1987. Hindustan Zinc Limited was impleaded as the ninth respondent at the instance of Respondents Nos.4 to 8. It has filed a counter-affidavit denying that it is responsible in any manner for causing any pollution in Bichri village or the surrounding areas. According to it, its plants are situated downstream, towards north of Bichri village. We do not think it necessary to refer to this affidavit in any detail inasmuch as we are not concerned, in this writ petition, with ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... on was about to set in, which would have further damaged the earth and water in the area, the Court directed the respondents to immediately remove the sludge from the open spaces where it was lying and store it in safe places to avoid the risk of seepage of toxic substances into the soil during the rainy season. The respondents were directed to complete the task within five weeks therefrom. It is not really necessary to refer to the contents of the various Orders passed in 1990 and 1991, i.e., subsequent to the Order dated April 4, 1990 for the present purposes. Suffice it to say that the respondents did not comply with the direction to store the sludge in safe places. The de- watering of wells did not prove possible. There was good amount of bickering between the respondents on one side and the R.P.C.B. and the Ministry of Environment and Forests on the other. They blamed each other for lack of progress in the matter of removal of sludge. Meanwhile, years rolled by and the hazard continued to rise. NEERI submitted an interim Report. [We are, however, not referring to the contents of this interim Report inasmuch as we would be referring to the contents of the final Report presen ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... y discharged on land by the unit, it is possible that this might have eroded soil and caused the extensive damage. It is also possible that the organic contents of the mother liquor would have gone into soil with water together with the reddish colour. The Report also suggested the mode of disposal of sludge and measures for re-conditioning the soil. In view of the above Report, the Court made an order on April 6, 1992 for entombing the sludge under the supervision of the officers of the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India. Regarding revamping of the soil, the Court observed that for this purpose, it might become necessary to stop or suspend the operation of all the units of the respondent but that, the Court said, requires to be examined further. The work of entombment of sludge again faced several difficulties. While the respondents blamed the Government officers for the delay, the Government officials blamed the said respondents of non-cooperation. Several Orders were passed by this Court in that behalf and ultimately, the work commenced. ORDERS PASSED IN 1993, FILING OF WRIT PETITION (C) NO.76 OF 1994 BY RESPONDENT NO.4 AND THE ORDERS PASSED THERE ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... aminated soil and sludge scraped from the sludge dump sites is disposed of in six lined entombed pits covered by lime/flyash mix, brick soling and concrete (Photographs 3 4). The remaining scraped sludge and contaminated soil was lying near the entombed pits for want of additional disposal facility. However, during the visit, the left over sludge and contaminated soil could not be traced at site. Inspection of the surrounding area revealed that a huge heap of foreign soil of 5 metre height (Photograph 5) covering a large area, as also indicated in Fig.1, was raised on the slopy ground at the foot hill within the industry premises. The storm water run-off pathway over the area showed indication of H-acid sludge leachate coming out of the heap. Soil in the area was sampled for analysis. 2.3 M/s.HACL has a number of other industrial units which are operating within the same premises without valid consents from the Rajasthan Pollution Control Board (RPCB). These plants are sulphuric acid (H2SO4), fertilizer (SSP) and vegetable oil extraction. The effluent of these units are not properly treated and the untreated effluent particularly from the acid plant is passing through the slud ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... n into account while ordering the closure. In its Order dated March 7, 1994, this Court found some justification in the contention of the industry that the various counter-affidavits filed by the R.P.C.B. are self-contradictory. The Board was directed to adopt a constructive attitude in the matter. By another Order dated March 18, 1994, the R.P.C.B. was directed to examine the issue of grant of permission to re-start the industry or to permit any interim arrangement in that behalf. On April 8, 1994, a 'consent' order was passed whereunder the industry was directed to deposit a sum of Rupees sixty thousand with R.P.C.B. before April 11, 1994 and the R.P.C.B. was directed to carry on the construction work of storage tank for storing and retaining ten days effluents from the Sulphuric Acid plant. The construction of temporary tank was supposed to be an interim measure pending the construction of an E.T.P. on permanent basis. The Order dated April 28, 1994 noted the Report of the R.P.C.B. stating that the construction of temporary tank was completed on April 26, 1994 under its supervision. The industry was directed to comply with such other requirements as may be pointed out by ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... sludge lying in the plant premises was entombed in the underground pit by RPCB as per the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. It may be mentioned that only 720 MT of sludge out of the estimated quantity of 2440 MT could be entombed as the capacity of the underground tanks provided by the industry for the purpose was only to that extent. * Remaining sludge and sludge mixed soil were, however, present in the plant premises as these could not be transferred into underground tanks. It has also been observed that only sludge above the soil was removed from the six sites and transferred to the plant site. Subsurface soil of these sites appears to have been contaminated as the soil has reddish colour akin to that of the sludge. * A fertilizer plant (single superphosphate), a sulphuric acid plant and an oil extraction and oil refining plant were in operation in the same premises where H-acid was earlier manufactured. The acidic wastewater (around pH 1.0) presently generated from these units was flowing over the abandoned dumpsite. This leaches the sludge mixed soil from the abandoned dumpsite and the contaminated water flows by gravity towards east and finds its way into ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... nation. Inter alia, the Report states: The entire contaminated area comprising of 350 ha of contaminated land and six abandoned dump sites outside the industrial premises has been found to be ecologically fragile due to reckless past disposal activities practiced by M/s. Silver Chemicals Ltd. and M/s.Jyoti Chemicals Ltd. Accordingly, it is suggested that the whole of the contaminated area be developed as a green belt at the expense of M/s.Hindustan Agrochemicals Ltd. during the monsoon of 1994. Under Para 6.3.2, the Report suggests Decontamination Alternatives for Groundwater including Bioremediation, Degradation of H-acid by Azotobacter Vinelandii, Isolation of Bacterial Population from H-acid Contaminated Soil and several other methods. Under Para 6.4.2, the Report mentions the several decontamination alternatives including containment of contaminated soil, surface control, ground water control, leachate collection and treatment, gas migration control and direct waste treatment. At Pages 157 and 158, the report mentions the continuing discharge of effluents in an illegal and dangerous manner. It reports: It was also observed by NEERI's team during the c ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... , the Report refers to the damage to the crops and the land and to the psychological and mental torture inflicted upon the villagers by the respondents and suggests that the principle of 'Polluter Pays' should be applied in this case inasmuch as the incident involved deliberate release of untreated acidic process wastewater and negligent handling of waste sludge knowing Fully well the implication of such acts. The Report suggests that compensation should be paid under two heads, viz., (a) for the losses due to damage and (b) towards the cost of restoration of environmental quality. It then works out the total cost of restoration of environmental quality at ₹ 3738.5 lakhs - i.e., ₹ 37.385 crores. Para 7.4 states the conclusions flowing from the material in Chapter-6 thus: The cost of damage to be disbursed to the affected villagers is estimated at ₹ 342.8 lakhs and remediation of impacted well waters and soil at ₹ 3738.5 lakhs. This cost needs to be borne by the management of the industry in keeping with the Polluter Pays principle and the doctrine of Strict/Absolute liability, as applied to Sri Ram Food and Fertilizers Industry in the case o ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... re is no machinery. A godown and a Ferric Alum plant have been constructed at the site of the said plant. The Ferric Alum plant was not in operation at the time of inspection though plant and machinery for manufacturing it was found installed therein. Certain old stock of Ferric Alum was also found lying within the plant premises. (2) Hindustan Agro-Chemicals Limited [R-4] has seven industrial plants, viz., Rajasthan Multi Fertilizers [manufacturing Grannulated Single Super Phosphate (G.S.S.P.)], a Suphuric Acid Plant, a Chlorosulphonic Acid Plant, Edible Oil Solvent Extraction Plant, Edible Oil Refinery and a Ferric Alum Plant (known as M/s.Jyoti Chemicals), all of which are located within the same premises. All these seven plants were found not operating on the date of inspection by the R.P.C.B. officials though in many cases the machinery and the other equipment was in place. So far as the sludge still remaining in the area is concerned, the report stated: 3. Village Bicchidi and other adjoining areas were visited by the undersigned officials to know whether gypsum and iron sludge is still lying in the aforesaid area. In area adjoining the irrigation canal, sludge mixed w ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... , learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, brought to our notice the several Reports, orders and other material on record. He submitted that the abundant material on record clearly establishes the culpability of the respondents for the devastation in village Bichhri and surrounding areas and their responsibility and obligation to properly store the remaining sludge, stop discharge of all untreated effluents by taking necessary measures and defray the total cost required for remedial measures as suggested by NEERI [Rupees forty crores and odd]. Learned counsel suggested that in view of the saga of repeated and continuous violation of law and lawful orders on the part of the respondents, they must be closed forthwith. So far as the legal propositions are concerned, the learned counsel relied strongly upon the Constitution Bench decision in M.C.Mehta v. Union of India [Oleum Gas Leak Case] (1987 (1) S.C.C.395) as well as the recent Order of this Court in Indian Council for Enviro- Legel Action v. Union of India [1995 (5) SCALE 578]. Learned counsel also invited our attention to quite a few foreign decisions and text books on the subject of environment. Sri Altaf Ahmed, learned Ad ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... s a fact and unjustified. (4) The respondents have been cooperating with this Court in all matters and carrying out its directions faithfully. The Report of the R.P.C.B. dated November 13, 1992 shows that the work of entombment of the sludge was almost over. The Report states that the entire sludge would be stored in the prescribed manner within the next two days. In view of this report, the subsequent Report of the Central team, R.P.C.B. and NEERI cannot be accepted or relied upon. There are about 70 industries in India manufacturing `H' acid. Only the units of the respondents have been picked upon by the Central and State authorities while taking no action against the other units. Even in the matter of disposal of sludge, the directions given for its disposal in the case of other units are not as stringent as have been prescribed in the case of respondents. The decision of the Gujarat High Court in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel shows that the method of disposal prescribed there is different and less elaborate than the one prescribed in this case. (5) The Reports submitted by the various so-called expert committees that sludge is still lying around within and outside the res ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... ation. Proceedings by way of a writ in this Court under Article 32 or in the High Court under Article 226, the learned counsel submitted, are not appropriate to deal with such matters, involve as they do several disputed questions of fact and technical issues. Before we proceed to deal with the submissions of the learned counsel, it would be appropriate to notice the relevant provisions of law. RELEVANT STATUTORY PROVISIONS: Article 48A is one of the Directive Principles of State Policy. It says that the State shall endeavor to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wildlife of the country. Article 51A sets out the fundamental duties of the citizens. One of them is (g) to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers and wild life and to have compassion for living creatures..... . The problem of increasing pollution of rivers and streams in the country - says the Statement of Objects and Reasons appended to the Bill which became the Water [Prevention and Control of Pollution] Act, 1974 - attracted the attention of the State Legislatures and the Parliament. They realised the urgency of ensuring that domestic a ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... utlets for the discharge of sewage or (c) begin to make any new discharge of sewage..... . [It is stated that the Rajasthan Assembly passed resolution under Article 252 of the Constitution adopting the said amendment Act vide Gazette Notification dated May 9, 1990.] Section 33 empowers the Pollution Control Board to apply to the court, not inferior to that of a Metropolitan Magistrate or a Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, to restrain any person causing pollution if the said pollution is likely to prejudicially affect water in a stream or a well. Section 33A, which has been introduced by Amendment Act 53 of 1988, empowers the Board to order the closure of any industry and to stop the electricity, water and any other service to such industry if it finds such a direction necessary for effective implementation of the provisions of the Act. Prior to the said amendment Act, the Pollution Control Board had no such power and the course open to it was to make a recommendation to the Government to pass appropriate orders including closure. The Air [Prevention and Control of Pollution] Act, 1981 contains similar provisions. In the year 1986, Parliament enacted a comprehensive leg ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... fe of the citizens of this country or of any section thereof, it is the duty of this Court to intervene. If it is found that the respondents are flouting the provisions of law and the directions and orders issued by the lawful authorities, this Court can certainly make appropriate directions to ensure compliance with law and lawful directions made thereunder. This is a social action litigation on behalf of the villagers of Bichhri whose right to life, as elucidated by this Court in several decisions, is invaded and seriously infringed by the respondents as is established by the various Reports of the experts called for, and filed before, this Court. If an industry is established without obtaining the requisite permission and clearances and if the industry is continued to be run in blatant disregard of law to the detriment of life and liberty of the citizens living in the vicinity, can it be suggested with any modicum of reasonableness that this Court has no power to intervene and protect the fundamental right to life and liberty of the citizens of this country. The answer, in our opinion, is self-evident. We are also not convinced of the plea of Sri Bhat that R.P.C.B. has been adop ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... her point of time but that is not the issue we are concerned with in these writ petitions. These writ petitions are confined to the pollution caused in Bichhri village on account of the activities of the respondent. No Report among the several Reports placed before us in these proceedings says that Hindustan Zinc Limited is responsible for the pollution at Bichhri village. Sri Bhat brought to our notice certain Reports stating that the discharges from Hindustan Zinc Limited were causing pollution in certain villages but they are all down stream, i.e., to the north of Bichhri village and we are not concerned with the pollution in those villages in these proceedings. The bringing in of Hindustan Zinc Limited in these proceedings is, therefore, not relevant. If necessary, the pollution, if any, caused by Hindustan Zinc Limited can be the subject-matter of a separate proceeding. We may now deal with the contentions of Sri Bhat based upon the affidavit of R.P.C.B. dated November 13, 1992 which has been repeatedly and strongly relied upon by the learned counsel in support of his submission that the entire sludge has been properly stored by or at the expense of his clients. It is on th ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... ther with the report of NEERI clearly establish that huge quantities of sludge were still lying around either in the form of mounds or placed in depressions, or spread over the contiguous areas and covered with local soil to conceal its existence. It is worth reiterating that the said sludge is only part of the pernicious discharges emanating from the manufacture of `H' acid. The other part, which is unfortunately not visible now [except in its deleterious effects upon the soil and underground water] is the `mother liquor' produced in enormous quantities which has either flowed out or percolated into the soil. So far as the responsibility of the respondents for causing the pollution in the wells, soil and the aquifers is concerned, it is clearly established by the analysis Report referred to in the Report of the Central experts team dated November 1, 1993 [Page 1026 of Vol.II]. Indeed, number of Orders passed by this Court, referred to hereinbefore, are premised upon the finding that the respondents are responsible for the said pollution. It is only because of the said reason that they were asked to defray the cost of removal and storage of sludge. It is precisely for th ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... any negligence on its part. Since the persons harmed on account of the hazardous or inherently dangerous activity carried on by the enterprise would not be in a position to isolate the process of operation from the hazardous preparation of substance or any other related element that caused the harm the enterprise must be held strictly liable for causing such harm as a part of the social cost for carrying on the hazardous or inherently dangerous activity. If the enterprise is permitted to carry on an hazardous or inherently dangerous activity for its profits, the law must presume that such permission is conditional on the enterprise absorbing the cost of any accident arising on account of such hazardous or inherently dangerous activity as an appropriate item of its overheads. Such hazardous or inherently dangerous activity for private profit can be tolerated only on condition that the enterprise engaged in such hazardous or inherently dangerous activity indemnifies all those who suffer on account of the carrying on of such hazardous or inherently dangerous activity regardless of whether it is carried on carefully or not...........We would therefore hold that where an enterprise is e ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... a decision has in terms been applied. In fact Bhagwati,C.J., clearly indicates in the judgment that his view is a departure from the law applicable to western countries. The majority judgment delivered by M.N.Venkatachaliah,J. [on behalf of himself and two other learned Judges] has not expressed any opinion on this issue. We on our part find it difficult to say, with great respect to the learned Chief Justice, that the law declared in Oleum Gas Leak Case is obiter. It does not appear to be unnecessary for the purposes of that case. Having declared the law, the Constitution Bench directed the parties and other organizations to institute actions on the basis of the law so declared.** Be that as it may, we are of the considered opinion that even if it is assumed [for the sake of argument] that this Court cannot award damages against the respondents in these proceedings that does not mean that the Court cannot direct the Central Government to determine and **A distinction between the Oleum Gas Leak Case and the present case may be noticed. That was not a case where the industry was established or was being operated contrary to law as in the present case. That was also not a c ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... red for carrying out remedial measures. This Court can certainly give directions to the Central Government/its delegate to take all such measures, if in a given case this Court finds that such directions are warranted. We find that similar directions have been made in a recent decision of this Court in Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action and Ors. [supra]. That was also a writ petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution. Following is the direction: It appears that the Pollution Control Board had identified as many as 22 industries responsible for the pollution caused by discharge of their effluents into Nakkavagu. They were responsible to compensate to farmers. It was the duty of the State Government to ensure that this amount was recovered from the industries and paid to the farmers. It is, therefore, idle to contend that this Court cannot make appropriate directions for the purpose of ensuring remedial action. It is more a matter of form. Sri K.N.Bhat submitted that the rule of absolute liability is not accepted in England or other Commonwealth countries and that the rule evolved by the House of Lords in Rylands v. Fletcher [1866 (3) H.L.330] is the correct r ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... necessarily involves decreasing of pelts. For that purpose, the defendant was using an oregano chlorine called P.C.E. P.C.E. was stored in a tank in the premises of the defendant. The plaintiff's case was that on account of the P.C.E. percolating into the ground, the water in its well became contaminated and unfit for human consumption and that on that account it was obliged to find an alternative source at a substantial cost. It sued the defendant for the resulting damages. The plaintiff based his claim on three alternative grounds, viz., negligence, nuisance and the rule in Rylands. The Trial Judge (High Court) dismissed the action in negligence and nuisance holding that the defendant could not have reasonably foreseen that such damage could occur to the plaintiff. So far as the rule in Rylands was concerned, the Trial Judge held that the user by the defendant was not an non-natural user and hence, it was not liable for damages. On appeal, the Court of Appeal declined to decide the matter on the basis of the rule in Rylands. It relied strongly upon the ratio in Ballard v. Tomlinson [(1885) 29 Ch.D.115] holding that no person having a right to use a common source is entitled t ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... of reasonable care to avoid a reasonably foreseeable risk of injury or damage to the person or property of another. In a case where a person or the property of that other is lawfully in a place outside the premises, the duty of care varies in degree according to the magnitude of the risk involved and extends to ensuring that such care is taken. Applying the said principle, the Court held that the Authority allowed the independent contractor to introduce or retain a dangerbus substance or to engage in a dangerous activity in its premises which substance and activity caused a fire that destroyed the goods of General Jones. The evidence, the Court held, established that the independent contractor's work was a dangerous activity in that it involved real and foreseeable risk of a serious conflagration unless special precautions were taken. In the circumstances, it was held that the Authority owed a non-delegable duty of care to General Jones to ensure that its contractor took reasonable steps to prevent the occurrence of a fire and the breach of that duty attracted liability pursuant to the ordinary principles of negligence for the damage sustained by the respondent. On a conside ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... Government the power to give directions of the above nature and to the above effect. Levy of costs required for carrying out remedial measures is implicit in Sections 3 and 4 which are couched in very wide and expansive language. Appropriate directions can be given by this Court to the Central Government to invoke and exercise those powers with such modulations as are called for in the facts and circumstances of this case. The question of liability of the respondents to defray the costs of remedial measures can also be looked into from another angle, which has now come to be accepted universally as a sound principle, viz., the Polluter Pays Principle. The polluter pays principle demands that the financial costs of preventing or remedying damage caused by pollution should lie with the undertakings which cause the pollution, or produce the goods which cause the pollution. Under the principle it is not the role of government to meet the costs involved in either prevention of such damage, or in carrying out remedial action, because the effect of this would be to shift the financial burden of the pollution incident to the taxpayer. The `polluter pays' principle was promoted ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... overnment, R.P.C.B. or such other agency or authority, as they think fit. The next question is what is the amount required for carrying out the necessary remedial measures to repair the damage and to restore the water and soil to the condition it was in before the respondents commenced their operations. The Report of NEERI has worked out the cost at wore than Rupees forty crores. The estimate of cost of remedial measures is, however, not a technical matter within the expertise of NEERI officials. Moreover, the estimate was made in the year 1994. Two years have passed by since then. Situation, if at all, must have deteriorated further on account of the presence of - and dispersal of the sludge - in and around the complex of the respondents by them. They have been discharging other toxic effluents from their other plants, as reported by NEERI and the central team. It is but appropriate that an estimate of the cost of remedial measures be made now with notice to the respondents, which amount should be paid to Central Government and/or recovered from them by the Central Government. Other directions are also called for in the light of the facts and circumstances mentioned above. C ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... assertion is made before us that permanent E.T.P. has also been constructed for the Sulphuric Acid Plant in addition to the temporary tank which was constructed under the Orders of this Court. We express no opinion on this assertion, which even if true, is valid only for the period subsequent to April, 1994. (III) The damage caused by the untreated highly toxic wastes resulting from the production of `H' acid - and the continued discharge of highly toxic effluent from the Sulphuric Acid Plant, flowing through the sludge [H-acid waste] - is undescribable. It has inflicted untold misery upon the villagers and long lasting damage to the soil, to the underground water and to the environment of that area in general. The Report of NEERI contains a sketch, at Page 178, showing the area that has been adversely affected by the production of `H' acid by the respondents. The area has been divided into three zones on the basis of the extent of contamination. A total area of 350 he has become seriously contaminated. The water in the wells in that area is not fit for consumption either by human beings or cattle. It has seriously affected the productivity of the land. According to NEER ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... n consultation with the experts of his Ministry within six weeks of the submission of the explanation by the said Respondents. The orders passed by the Secretary, [M.E.F.] shall be communicated to Respondents 4 to 8 - and all concerned - and shall also be placed before this Court. Subject to the Orders, if any, passed by this Court, the said amount shall represent the amount which Respondents 4 to 8 are liable to pay to improve and restore the environment in the area. For the purpose of these proceedings, the Secretary, [M.E.F.] and Respondents 4 to 8 shall proceed on the assumption that the affected area is 350 ha, as indicated in the sketch at Page 178 of NEERI Report. In case of failure of the said respondents to pay the said amount, the same shall be recovered by the Central Government in accordance with law. The factories, plant, machinery and all other lmmovable assets of Respondents 4 to 8 are attached herewith. The amount so determined and recovered shall be utilised by the M.E.F. for carrying out all necessary remedial measures to restore the soil, water sources and the environment in general of the affected area to its former state. 2. On account of their continuous, p ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... made in this behalf as between a large-scale industry and a small-scale industry or for that matter between a large-scale industry and a medium- scale industry. All chemical industries, whether big or small, should be allowed to be established only after taking into considerations all the environmental aspects and their functioning should be monitored closely to ensure that they do not pollute the environment around them. It appears that most of these industries are water-intensive industries. If so, the advisability of allowing the establishment of these industries in arid areas may also require examination. Even the existing chemical industries may be subjected to such a study and if it is found on such scrutiny that it is necessary to take any steps in the interests of environment, appropriate directions in that behalf may be issued under Sections 3 and 5 of the Environment Act. The Central Government shall ensure that the directions given by it are implemented forthwith. 5. The Central Government and the R.P.C.B. shall file quarterly Reports before this Court with respect to the progress in the implementation of Directions 1 to 4 aforesaid. 6. The suggestion for establish ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X
|
