Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - doctrine of res judicata - ...

Income Tax

May 31, 2023

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - doctrine of res judicata - principal of consistency - Consistency does not mean putting iron fetters on the subsequent decision making; it only means expecting that a deviation from the previous decision in similar set of circumstances is explained by way of cogent and rational reasons. In the present case, the decision taken first in point of time (order dated 28.07.2022) was a reasoned decision, based on the analysis of material on record, but the decision taken subsequently (order dated 31.07.2022) not just took a view completely inconsistent with the previous view but even without an iota of reason. - notice cannot sustain and set aside - HC

View Source

← Previous Next →

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - doctrine of res judicata - ...

Income Tax

May 31, 2023

You may also like:

Principle of res judicata – Constructive res judicata - if any issue or matter decided by the Court or Authority not having jurisdiction the principle of res judicata...

Applicability of doctrine of finality and res-judicata - The High Court held that, the principles of res-judicata do not apply squarely for one assessment year to the...

Doctrine of res judicata - The previous year’s assessment order in fact did not lead any discussion on this aspect and appear to have merely accepted the assessee’s...

Principles of res-judicata - Res judicata cannot apply solely because the issue has previously come up before the court. The doctrine will apply where the issue has been...

Doctrine of Res judicata – There is no question of its being a res judicata so as to bind the A.O. appellate authority or the Tribunal in tax matters so as to decide the...

Supply of items for setting up independent thermal power plant - Supply against International Competitive Bidding (ICB) - Going by the maxim res judicata pro veritate...

Exemption of Tax - Classification – Common salt – Res Judicata - what is excluded from exemption is only the 'salt for industrial use' and not the 'common salt' - HC

Deduction u/s 80IC - prohibited category of business - principle of res-judicata - on the principle of consistency, learned CIT(A) was justified in directing the...

Rule of consistency - for the period of about 15 years, assesse’s submissions the annual amortization of the initial lease consideration, as advance rent was accepted -...

CIRP - Principles of res-judicata - Once the order of the Adjudicating Authority attains finality on account of affirmation by the Hon’ble Apex Court in appeal, the same...

Quick Updates: