Detention of goods on incorrect grounds - when the show-cause ...

Goods Detention Challenged: Court Rules Revenue's Grounds Invalid, Finds Detention Order Legally Flawed.

January 2, 2024

Case Laws GST HC

Detention of goods on incorrect grounds - when the show-cause notice was issued, there is no whisper of any invalid document whatsoever. In fact, the stand was completely changed by the Revenue and this volte face cannot be countenanced by this Court. The detention of goods causes serious prejudice to an assessee and the same can only be done on the basis of specific, valid and reasonable grounds - In the present case, it is quite obvious that at the time of detention, the ground that was stated by the Revenue was incorrect - The detention order and the subsequent SCN were bad in law - HC

View Source

← Previous Next →

Detention of goods on incorrect grounds - when the show-cause ...

Goods Detention Challenged: Court Rules Revenue's Grounds Invalid, Finds Detention Order Legally Flawed.

January 2, 2024

Case Laws GST HC

You may also like:

Prevention Detention Order - Smuggling of gold - the order of detention passed for more than two grounds and if one of the grounds is not applicable or vague or...

Wavier of demurrage/storage charges - Detention of the goods - Seeking release the goods for export - The court noted the CESTAT's decision, finding the detention of...

Detention of goods - detention based on statement of driver regarding place of unloading of goods - route for transportation of goods disputed - The power of detention...

Detention of goods and Levy of penalty on the ground of under valuation - The High court quashed the impugned orders for wrongly penalizing the petitioner based on...

Detention of goods alongwith vehicle - Section 129 of the GST Act - The detention of the vehicle and the goods was on the finding that the goods on inspection were found...

Detention of goods - surgical gloves - detention on the ground that the goods were not accompanied by the document provided for under Rule 138(2) State SGST Rules - HC...

Detention of goods on onward journey - detention on ground goods dispatched to different place than mentioned in documents - levy of penalty u/s 129 of UPGST Act -...

Detention of consignment alongwith vehicle - inter-state sale - There is no material placed on record by the 1st respondent to show that any attempt was made by the...

Detaining authority is under obligation to comply with the requirements by formulating grounds for detention - HC

Detention of goods - foreign bike - smuggling - detention on the ground that the appellant could not produce any documents evidencing the legal import of the bike -...

Detention of goods alongwith vehicle - e-way bill generated for return of goods without issuing credit note - The detention of the goods was per se illegal and...

Refund of CGST u/s 54 - it was found that the vehicles mentioned in two invoices were not registered on the e-vahan portal. - Having established that the foundation of...

HC quashed detention order of goods after determining no substantive discrepancy existed between physical verification report (MOV-04) and accompanying documents. The...

HC examined validity of detention and seizure notice under GST Act Section 129(3). Referring to government circular dated 31-12-2018 defining ownership of goods through...

Detention order - inordinate delay of thirty years in the execution of the detention order - In the facts of this case, no attempts had been made to contact or arrest...

Quick Updates: