Home Case Index All Cases Indian Laws Indian Laws + HC Indian Laws - 2021 (12) TMI HC This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2021 (12) TMI 1105 - CALCUTTA HIGH COURTRestraint on invocation of a bank guarantee - alleged short-supply of goods - fraud or irrevocable injury or special equities which would vitiate the entire underlying transaction - HELD THAT:- Courts are usually slow to interfere with the transaction between a bank and the beneficiary which is seen as being independent of the underlying contract between the lender and the supplier unless conditions call for such interference. The three conditions, as accepted in several decisions, are fraud of an egregious nature; special equities or the invocation not being in terms of the bank guarantee. It is sufficient if a party seeking a restraint on the invocation is able to establish any one of the three requirements. The test of special equity or irrevocable injustice is a matter of an assessment by a court on the particular facts presented to it for stay on a notice of invocation. The injury or injustice must be irrevocable, irremediable and irreversible In the present case, the petitioner has satisfied two of the three ingredients, namely special equity and the invocation not being in terms of the guarantee. The clauses in the contract and more particularly the GCC clearly demonstrate that the bank guarantee was furnished towards performance security. There can be no issue with regard to performance since the petitioner has already received 90% of the contract price as discussed above. The invocation letter also demonstrates that there cannot be any performance issue with regard to the supplies effected by the petitioner. The invocation letter does not contain any allegation of a breach of performance obligations by the petitioner. The special equity also stands satisfied by reason of the petitioner facing an immediate and irreversible financial loss if the payment is made by Citibank NA, Dhaka to the respondent No. 1 in terms of the Letter of Invocation. Application disposed off.
|