Forgot password
New User/ Regiser
⇒ Register to get Live Demo
1963 (8) TMI 30 - SC - VAT and Sales Tax
Whether there can be a valid agreement under Article 278 of the Constitution in respect of taxes leviable by the State and not leviable by the Government of India till an appropriate law is made by Parliament?
Held that:- Appeal allowed. The Constitution gives a separate treatment to the subject of finance, and Article 277 saves the existing taxes etc. levied by States, if the conditions mentioned therein are complied with. While Article 372 saves all pre-Constitution valid laws, Article 277 is confined only to taxes, duties, cesses or fees lawfully levied immediately before the Constitution. Therefore, Article 372 cannot be construed in such a way as to enlarge the scope of the saving of taxes, duties, cesses or fees. To state it differently, Article 372 must be read subject to Article 277. We have already held that an agreement can be entered into between the Union and the States in terms of Article 278 abrogating or modifying the power preserved to the States under Article 277.