TMI Blog2014 (6) TMI 79X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... and filed income tax returns in accordance with the law. A curative amendment to avoid unintended consequences is to be treated as retrospective in nature even though it may not state so specifically, the insertion of second proviso must be given retrospective effect from the point of time when the related legal provision was introduced - it cannot subscribe to the view that it could have been an "intended consequence" to punish the assessees for non-deduction of tax at source by declining the deduction in respect of related payments, even when the corresponding income is duly brought to tax - That will be going much beyond the obvious intention of the section - the insertion of second proviso to Section 40(a)(ia) is declaratory and curative in nature and it has retrospective effect from 1st April, 2005, being the date from which sub clause (ia) of section 40(a) was inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 – thus, the matter is remitted back to the AO for fresh adjudication – Decided in favour of Assessee. - I.T.A. No.:337/Agra/2013 - - - Dated:- 29-5-2014 - Bhavnesh Saini, JM, and Pramod Kumar, JJ. Dr. Rakesh Gupta for the Appellant Radha Sharma for the Responde ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... terial on record and duly considered factual matrix of the case as also the applicable legal position. 4. Let us first take a look at the legislative amendment of section 40(a)(ia), vide Finance Act 2012, and try to appreciate the scheme of things as evident in the amended section. Second proviso to Section 40(a)(ia), introduced with effect from 1st April 2013, provides, that where an assessee fails to deduct the whole or any part of the tax in accordance with the provisions of Chapter XVII-B on any such sum but is not deemed to be an assessee in default under the first proviso to sub-section (1) of section 201, then, for the purpose of this sub-clause, it shall be deemed that the assessee has deducted and paid the tax on such sum on the date of furnishing of return of income by the resident payee referred to in the said proviso . In other words, as long as the assessee cannot be treated as an assessee in default, the disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) cannot come into play either. To understand the effect of this proviso, it is useful to refer to first proviso to section 201(1), which is also introduced by the Finance Act 2012and effective1st July 2012, and which provides th ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... een given effect prospectively . It was held that if the consequences sought to be remedied by the subsequent amendments were to be treated as intended consequences , the amendment could not be treated as retrospective in effect. The special bench then proceeded to draw a line of demarcation between intended consequences and unintended consequences, and finally the retrospectivity of first proviso was decided against the assessee on the ground that this special bench was of the considered view that the objective sought to be achieved by bringing out section 40(a)(ia) is the augmentation of TDS provisions and went on to add that If, in attaining this main objective of augmentation of such provisions, the assessee suffers disallowance of any amount in the year of default, which is otherwise deductible, the legislature allowed it to continue . It was further observed that this is the cost which parliament has awarded to those assessees who fail to comply with the relevant provisions by considering overall objective of boosting TDS compliance (Emphasis by underlining supplied by us). In other words, the amendment was held to be prospective because, in the wisdom of the special ben ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... is not allowed to the assessees, in cases where assessees had tax withholding obligations from the related payments, without corresponding income inclusion by the recipient.That is the clearly discernable bigger picture, and, unmistakably, a very pragmatic and fair policy approach to the issue - howsoever belated the realization of unintended and undue hardships to the taxpayers may have been. It seems to proceed on the basis, and rightly so, that seeking tax deduction at source compliance is not an end in itself, so far as the scheme of this legal provision is concerned, but is only a mean of recovering due taxes on income embedded in the payments made by the assessee. That's how, as we have seen a short while ago, Hon'ble Delhi High Court has visualized the scheme of things - as evident from Their Lordships' reference to augmentation of recoveries in the context of loss of revenue and depriving the Government of the tax due and payable . 8. With the benefit of this guidance from Hon'ble Delhi High Court, in view of legislative amendments made from time to time, which throw light on what was actually sought to be achieved by this legal provision, and in the ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... ght to tax in the hands of the recipient. The scheme of Section 40(a)(ia), as we see it, is aimed at ensuring that an expenditure should not be allowed as deduction in the hands of an assessee in a situation in which income embedded in such expenditure has remained untaxed due to tax withholding lapses by the assessee. It is not, in our considered view, a penalty for tax withholding lapse but it is a sort of compensatory deduction restriction for an income going untaxed due to tax withholding lapse. The penalty for tax withholding lapse per se is separately provided for in Section 271 C, and, section 40(a)(ia) does not add to the same. The provisions of Section 40(a)(ia), as they existed prior to insertion of second proviso thereto, went much beyond the obvious intentions of the lawmakers and created undue hardships even in cases in which the assessee's tax withholding lapses did not result in any loss to the exchequer. Now that the legislature has been compassionate enough to cure these shortcomings of provision, and thus obviate the unintended hardships, such an amendment in law, in view of the well settled legal position to the effect that a curative amendment to avoid unint ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X
|
