9911796707
|
Home
Issues:
1. Time-barred assessment under section 39(6) of the Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1991. 2. Applicability of limitation under section 41 for reassessment. 3. General period of limitation for completing assessment under section 39(6). Issue 1: Time-barred assessment under section 39(6) of the Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1991: The assessee, a charitable trust, filed a return in May 1994 and was assessed to a net agricultural income of Rs. 2,28,560 for the year 1993-94. The contention was that the assessment order passed on June 15, 1998, exceeded the two-year limitation period as per section 39(6) of the Act. However, the appellate authority and the Tribunal rejected this claim. The court analyzed the provisions of section 39(6) which mandate completion of assessments within two years from the date of filing the return. It was clarified that the time-limit applies to returns filed under section 35, and since the return in question was filed after the due date, it did not fall under section 35(1). The court emphasized the relevance of the Explanation added by the Finance Act, 2000, and concluded that the assessment order was not time-barred under section 39(6). Issue 2: Applicability of limitation under section 41 for reassessment: The second issue raised was whether the limitation under section 41 for reassessment should apply instead of section 39(6) for the original assessment. Section 41 allows for reassessment within ten years if income has escaped assessment. The court clarified that the time-limit under section 41 is indeed ten years, and since the final assessment order was within this period, the assessment was not time-barred under section 41. Therefore, the Tribunal's decision to consider the limitation under section 41 as applicable was upheld. Issue 3: General period of limitation for completing assessment under section 39(6): Lastly, the court addressed the absence of an express provision during the relevant period of 1993-94 regarding returns filed after the due date. It was argued whether the general period of limitation under section 39(6) should apply in such cases. The court reiterated that the time-limit under section 39(6) applies to returns filed under section 35 and not to voluntary filings after the due date. By referencing the provisions of section 41 and the Explanation added by the Finance Act, 2000, the court confirmed that the assessment order in question was not time-barred. The court also cited a previous Division Bench judgment supporting this interpretation. In conclusion, the court dismissed the revision as lacking merit, affirming that the assessment order was not time-barred under the provisions of the Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1991.
|
