HC held that GST-ASMT-10 notices issued under Section 61 of ...

Challenging GST Assessment: Stone-Boulder Sales Price Comparison Invalidated Under Section 61 of Jharkhand GST Act

May 12, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

HC held that GST-ASMT-10 notices issued under Section 61 of Jharkhand GST Act, 2017 comparing petitioners' stone-boulder sales price with market price are ultra vires and without jurisdiction. The court determined that merely selling goods at a lower than market price does not automatically constitute a taxable discrepancy. The notices were deemed improper as they exceeded statutory powers, and the court quashed the notices, effectively ruling in favor of the petitioners by invalidating the tax department's assessment approach.

View Source

← Previous

HC held that GST-ASMT-10 notices issued under Section 61 of ...

Challenging GST Assessment: Stone-Boulder Sales Price Comparison Invalidated Under Section 61 of Jharkhand GST Act

May 12, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

You may also like:

GST Rates - HSN Code - Footwear having a retail sale price not exceeding ₹ 500 per pair [provided that such retail sale price is indelibly marked or embossed on...

Assessment of sales shown in accounts at low prices - Benefit of exemption from VAT - sale of footwear - The language of the section is specific insofar as it states...

Bogus sale - allegation of unaccounted sale to the petrol pump owners/other industries - the sale price declared by the assessee was accepted by the sales tax department...

Levy of differential Additional Duty of Customs - Valuation for CVD - In this case since the goods are not sold to the consumer there cannot be a retail sale price. The...

GST Rates - HSN Code - Readymade garments of sale value not exceeding ₹ 1000 per piece attract 5% GST. Readymade garments of sale value exceeding ₹ 1000 per...

E-commerce business - Selling at a price lower than the cost price - unless certain provisions such as Section 145(3)are invoked, the AO is not empowered to go beyond...

Addition u/s 80I/80IA - crushing of shop stone - the outcome being the soap stone powder of different grades is a different and distinct marketable article from the...

Recovery of loss of revenue – Whether reduction in rate of Entry Tax/ VAT is against the interest of State of Bihar – stone chips, stone boulders and stone ballasts -...

Understatement of sales price / turnover - there was no allegation by the Revenue that the assessee by making the sale at a price lower than the cost of purchase has...

Valuation - sale of Gypsum - mere bifurcation of the sale price of the goods in a mutual contract between the parties under a separate bargain or even a common bargain...

The GST Council approved formation of a GoM on restructuring Compensation Cess to examine revenue impacts on states post-GST implementation. Key points: Karnataka raised...

Refund claim - order of assessment in appeal not challenged - The Tribunal acknowledged the appellants' arguments regarding the contractual agreement and the price...

Valuation of goods - method of valuation - sale of goods from depot / customer care center - It is found that the form in which the goods have been sold at depot are in...

TP Adjustment - Naturally when sales price consists of price for warranty and After sales services, which are promised at the time of sales, naturally corresponding...

Benefit of sales tax exemption - sale price were same from the exempted and non-exempted units - Uniform pricing cannot be a ground to hold that the respondent was...

Quick Updates: