HC dismissed the writ petition on grounds of alternative remedy ...

Transshipment Penalty Dismissed: Technical Portal Errors Not Sufficient Grounds for Direct Writ Challenge, Appellate Remedy Preferred

May 22, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

HC dismissed the writ petition on grounds of alternative remedy being available. The petitioner challenged penalty and e-way bill validity arising from technical portal errors during transshipment due to vehicle breakdown. Despite contentions regarding bill extension and portal glitches, the court held that the appellate authority remains competent to examine all substantive and procedural aspects if an appeal is filed in accordance with law. The petition was consequently rejected, emphasizing exhaustion of statutory remedies before seeking extraordinary writ jurisdiction.

View Source

← Previous Next →

HC dismissed the writ petition on grounds of alternative remedy ...

Transshipment Penalty Dismissed: Technical Portal Errors Not Sufficient Grounds for Direct Writ Challenge, Appellate Remedy Preferred

May 22, 2025

Case Laws GST HC

You may also like:

Levy of maximum penalty - penalty imposed on the basis of technical error - non downloading of E-way Bill-01 - The Allahabad High Court reviewed the matter and set aside...

Difference between assessed income and returned income arose due to inadvertent error in taking opening written down value (WDV) at book value instead of WDV under...

Levy of penalty for violation of section 129 and Rule 138 - Failure to update the E-way bill on change of vehicle after breakdown - The imposition of penalties for mere...

Levy of Penalty u/s 129(3) of the Central Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 - Errors in e-way bills - The Court emphasized that minor typographical errors in e-way bills,...

Levy of tax / penalty - error with regard to the address of the consignee in the E-Way Bill - The High court observes that in numerous judgments, it has been established...

Penalty order - Part-B of the e-way bill was not filled up - intent to evade tax - The High court, referencing a previous judgment, ruled that such technical errors, in...

Imposition of tax and penalty u/s 129(3) - e-way bill had expired nine hours and thirty minutes prior to interception - The High court referred to previous cases where...

Violation of principles of natural justice - technical glitch - Despite the Department's submission that the petitioner had been informed in advance about the correct...

Refund claim of unutilized ITC used in making zero-rated supply of goods - Technical error / arithmetical error committed by the employee - It is settled law that the...

Benefits under the MEIS denied - denial solely on the ground of a seeming technical error especially when the eligibility of the writ-applicant is not disputed - It is a...

ITAT held that penalty u/s 270A(9)(a) for under-reporting of income is deleted. The appellant, a salaried employee, demonstrated a bona fide mistake by relying on tax...

Goods detained on ground of non-generation of E-Tax Invoice as per Rule 48 of GST Rules before movement; all required documents u/r 138A accompanied goods; technical...

Condonation of delay in filing the appeal - delay of 326 days - sufficient cause - After considering the arguments and perusing the materials, the Tribunal found that...

CBIC implemented significant trade facilitation measures for air cargo and transhipment, effective 24th April 2025. Key changes include waiving transhipment permit fees,...

CBIC has extended the transitional provisions for the Sea Cargo Manifest and Transhipment Regulations (SCMTR) until May 31, 2025. While arrival messages by carriers have...

Quick Updates: