SC dismissed SLP challenging rejection of Order VII Rule 11 CPC ...

Property Ownership Dispute: Plaint Challenges Limited by Lack of Direct Knowledge and Procedural Constraints Under Rule 11 CPC

May 22, 2025

Case Laws Indian Laws SC

SC dismissed SLP challenging rejection of Order VII Rule 11 CPC application. The court held that subsequent property purchasers cannot challenge plaint maintainability without direct knowledge of property's original ownership status. The court emphasized that benami transaction exceptions involve disputed factual questions inappropriate for plaint rejection at preliminary stage. Section 14 of Benami Act does not prohibit property suits, and parties retain right to contest substantive issues on merits. No prejudice or miscarriage of justice was established, rendering special leave petitions non-maintainable.

View Source

← Previous Next →

SC dismissed SLP challenging rejection of Order VII Rule 11 CPC ...

Property Ownership Dispute: Plaint Challenges Limited by Lack of Direct Knowledge and Procedural Constraints Under Rule 11 CPC

May 22, 2025

Case Laws Indian Laws SC

You may also like:

The Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020 aims to settle tax disputes. The term "appeal" under the Act includes writ petitions challenging tax orders, as per Supreme...

Exemption from payment of property tax under the provisions of the UP Municipal Corporation Adhiniyam, 1959 - The Supreme Court held that, the enemy properties vest in...

The case involves property forfeiture under SAFEMA, which was also part of TADA proceedings. The Appellant's challenge based on different statutes was rejected. The...

Section 16 of the Companies Act grants the Central Government, through the Regional Director (RD), the power to rectify a company's name. Subsection (1) allows...

Valuation of the property under gift - Assessment u/s 15(2) of the Gift Tax Act determining the taxable gift - The assessee or her legal heir is now contesting the...

Authority under the Customs Act to proceed against the property of a third party - Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions - The High Court emphasizes that...

Ownership of shares - time limitation to claim ownership - The applicant, it appears, discovered, in and about April-June 1997 (after a gaop of about 4 years), that its...

The Appellate Tribunal adjudicated on the issue of addition of interest income and penalty u/s 271(1)(c). The assessee contended that the interest income from a Fixed...

SC held that the plaint must be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) CPC due to absence of cause of action. An agreement to sell does not confer substantive...

Comparable selection for determining arm's length price (ALP) adjustment. Appeals limited to including or excluding certain uncontrolled entities as comparables...

The CESTAT dismissed the appellant's challenge to service tax levied on one-time premium collected for renting immovable property. Following the Allahabad HC decision in...

HC ruled that mere signatory status on property conveyance does not automatically establish ownership or tax liability under Income Tax Act. Section 26 and 27 require...

Penalty imposed u/s 114(1) of the Customs Act, 1962 for alleged abetment of illegal export by arranging lorries. Lack of admissible evidence showing knowledge of goods...

Penalty u/s 271D for violation of Section 269SS was challenged. ITAT held that where assessee received sale consideration for immovable property in cash exceeding Rs....

Legal interpretation of the term "original asset" for claiming exemption u/s 54F of the Income Tax Act. It discusses the ownership rights over the "original asset" by...

Quick Updates: