Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2024 (1) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2024 (1) TMI 1181 - ITAT DELHIClubbing of income of Non-resident and Permanent Establishment (PE) - Levy of surcharge at 5% as against assessee’s claim of 2% as clubbing the total amount exceeded the threshold limit of Rs. 10 lakhs - whether the royalty and FTS income can be subjected to levy of surcharge, as provided under the domestic law? HELD THAT:- Taxability of royalty and FTS has been dealt under Article 12 of India – Germany DTAA. As per Article 12(2) of the treaty, royalty and FTS can be taxed in the source state at a rate not exceeding 10% of the gross amount, if the recipient is the beneficial owner of such royalty and FTS. Undoubtedly, the assessee, being a beneficial owner of royalty and FTS, has offered to tax the royalty and FTS on gross basis by applying rate of 10%. This, in our view, is in compliance with the treaty provisions. Therefore, further levy on account of surcharge exceeds the rate of 10%, hence, cannot be levied on royalty/FTS income, as, it would be in violation of Article 12(2) read with Article 2 of India – Germany DTAA. To get over the mandatory condition of Article 12(2) of the Act, learned first appellate authority has made an attempt to link royalty/FTS income to the Supervisory PE. Neither it is the case of the assessee that such income is linked to the PE, nor the department has brought any material on record to demonstrate that royalty and FTS income is effectively connected to the PE. Therefore, in our view, the royalty and FTS income offered by the assessee has to be essentially governed under the treaty provisions and not under the domestic law. Thus, in our view, the Departmental Authorities have erroneously clubbed the royalty and FTS income with the income of the PE for the purpose of surcharge at the rate of 5%. Direct the AO to accept assessee’s computation and delete the extra demand raised on the assessee, both on account of surcharge as well as consequential demand relating to cess and interest. Decided in favour of assessee.
|